Public notice of open meetings and the online publication of such notice

Summary#

Int. 867, sponsored by Council Member Harvey D. Epstein, would amend the New York City Administrative Code. It would require the Information Technology and Telecommunications Commissioner, working with the Civic Engagement Commission, to provide a searchable website and mobile app for open-meeting notices. The bill’s stated aim is public notice; it is not yet law and is waiting in committee.

  • City agencies and advisory bodies would have to prepare a notice for each open meeting. It must include the meeting’s subject, time and place, known representatives or guests, whether the public may participate, and how to access any livestream or videoconference.
  • They would have to send the notice to the Commissioner or a designee, or publish it directly if the Commissioner permits. For meetings scheduled at least a week ahead, notice must be submitted at least 72 hours beforehand; for meetings scheduled less than a week ahead, it must be submitted at a reasonable time before the meeting, to the extent practicable.
  • The website and app would have to allow searches and filters for the convening agency or advisory body, date, remote public participation, and borough where applicable. No account could be required.
  • Adjudicatory hearings about violations would be exempt. A notice-rule violation alone would not invalidate an agency’s or advisory body’s action or prevent a required meeting from being held.

What it means for you#

  • People seeking to attend meetings: You could use one city website or app to find notices and details about attending or participating. The bill does not require agencies to let the public speak; notices must say whether participation is allowed.
  • City agencies and advisory bodies: They would have to prepare and submit or publish notices, subject to the different timing rules above.
  • People involved in adjudicatory hearings: Those hearings are excluded from this notice system.

Money#

No cost information is provided in the available material.

  • The bill requires the Commissioner to provide a website and app, but gives no cost, staffing, or funding estimate.

What is unclear#

  • “Reasonable time” and “to the extent practicable” are not defined, so the timing for meetings scheduled less than a week ahead is not exact.
  • The bill does not set out penalties or a separate process to enforce the notice duties. It does specify that a violation alone does not invalidate an agency action or prevent a required meeting.
  • The bill does not give a start date on the calendar; it would take effect 180 days after becoming law.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that one searchable, account-free site and app could make it easier for the public to find open meetings.
  • The required notices would include practical details about the meeting and whether or how the public can join remotely or participate.

Case against#

  • One concern is that the notice timing for meetings scheduled less than a week ahead depends on undefined terms, which may leave the public with little advance notice.
  • Agencies and advisory bodies would have new notice duties, and the city would have to provide the website and app, but the bill supplies no cost estimate.
  • The bill does not specify a penalty or other enforcement process, and a notice violation alone would not invalidate the agency’s action.