Establishing a pilot program to waive license fees for sidewalk cafes and roadway cafes in certain council districts

Summary#

Introduction 1092-2026, sponsored by Council Member Justin E. Sanchez, would create a two-year pilot program; it does not amend the cited Administrative Code section. The Department of Transportation (DOT) would waive fees set under that section for sidewalk-cafe and roadway-cafe licenses granted or renewed in the 10 council districts with the fewest active licenses on the law’s effective date. The stated goal is to test the fee waiver and report on the results; the bill is waiting in committee and is not law.

  • The pilot must start 90 days after the local law takes effect and last two years.
  • DOT must submit a report to the mayor and Council speaker, and post it online, no later than 90 days after the pilot ends.
  • The report must include before-and-after counts and percentage differences for both types of cafes in each covered district, the city’s spending to carry out licensing, and a recommendation with an explanation about whether to make the program permanent.

What it means for you#

  • Cafe operators: If your sidewalk-cafe or roadway-cafe license is granted or renewed in one of the 10 covered districts during the pilot, its license fee would be waived. The bill does not provide a refund for fees already paid.
  • DOT: The commissioner must establish and run the pilot, then prepare and publish the required report.
  • Other districts and businesses: The waiver would not apply to licenses in districts outside the 10 selected. The bill does not directly change other licensing rules.

Money#

No cost estimate or fee and revenue totals are provided.

  • The city would forgo the covered license fees, but the bill gives no estimate of the revenue involved.
  • DOT must carry out the program and report the city’s spending on licensing. The bill gives no staffing or implementation cost estimate.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not explain how DOT would administer the waiver or what happens if a license fee has already been paid.
  • The 10 districts are selected by active-license counts on the effective date, but the text does not explain how ties would be handled.
  • The bill requires counts and percentage changes, but does not require a comparison with districts outside the pilot or explain how to assess whether the waiver caused any change.
  • The cited Administrative Code section and cafe definitions are not included in the supplied material, so the current fee amounts and full licensing rules could not be verified.

Case for#

  • The bill targets districts with the fewest active sidewalk-cafe and roadway-cafe licenses. A possible argument for the waiver is that reducing fees there could encourage more cafe licenses.
  • The required before-and-after counts and cost information could help the city assess whether to continue the program.

Case against#

  • The city would give up fee revenue and take on program costs, but the bill does not estimate either amount.
  • The report’s counts before and after the pilot may show what changed, but the bill does not require a method to determine whether the waiver caused that change.
  • The bill does not explain why having fewer active licenses is the right basis for selecting districts, or how ties in the counts would be resolved.