Impose an additional tax on certain non-primary residence class one and class two properties in New York City. (A.1814)

Summary#

Res 0170-2026 is a City Council resolution, sponsored by Council Member Nantasha M. Williams. It does not change city law; it calls on the New York State Legislature to pass A.1814 and the Governor to sign it. The resolution’s stated goal is to encourage certain non-primary homes to become available for rent or sale and raise revenue for affordable housing.

  • As described in the resolution, A.1814 would authorize New York City to impose a graduated additional property tax on certain non-primary residences: properties with a five-year average market value of at least $5 million, and condominium or co-operative units meeting an assessed-value threshold of $300,000.
  • The resolution says the City could impose, administer, collect and enforce the tax like other property taxes. A.1814’s text was not supplied, so these details could not be checked against that bill.
  • The resolution was introduced and referred to committee on January 29, 2026. It is waiting in committee; no vote is recorded.

What it means for you#

  • Owners of affected properties: This resolution itself creates no tax and requires no action. If A.1814 became law and the City chose to impose the tax, some owners could owe additional property tax.
  • Other New Yorkers: The resolution asks state lawmakers and the Governor to act. It does not require the City to create or fund an affordable-housing program.

Money#

The resolution cites a potential average of $258 million per fiscal year in additional tax revenue for FY2025 through FY2027, based on a 2023 estimate by the New York City Comptroller’s Office.

  • That is an estimate cited in the resolution, not revenue raised by this resolution. No tax rates or City cost estimate are provided.
  • The resolution says revenue could support affordable-housing programs; it does not require that use.

What is unclear#

  • A.1814’s text is not included, so its exact tax rates, calculation rules, exemptions and start date: No publicly available information.
  • The resolution does not say how the City would determine whether a home is a non-primary residence or how owners could challenge a tax assessment.
  • It is unclear whether A.1814 would require the City to impose the tax or only give it permission to do so.

Case for#

  • The resolution’s sponsors cite a 1.41% city vacancy rate and 58,810 homes unavailable for rent or sale because they were held for seasonal, recreational or occasional use.
  • The sponsors argue that a tax could discourage keeping some homes unavailable and raise money that could support affordable housing.
  • The resolution cites the Comptroller’s estimate that the tax could raise an average of $258 million per year over FY2025–FY2027.

Case against#

  • A possible trade-off is that owners of qualifying non-primary residences could face an additional tax. The resolution does not provide rates or explain how the tax burden would vary.
  • The resolution does not show that taxing these homes would make them available to rent or buy, or that any revenue would be used for affordable housing.