Bottle Redemption Fraud Task Force. ( A.3469)

Summary#

Res. 0174-2026 is a New York City Council resolution, sponsored by Council Member Nantasha M. Williams, asking the New York State Legislature to pass and the Governor to sign A.3469. It would not change New York City law or create the task force; that would require state action. The resolution says the task force’s goal would be to study fraud involving New York’s bottle-deposit system and report findings and recommendations to the Governor and State Legislature.

  • As described in the resolution, A.3469 would create a 15-member state task force chaired by the Attorney General or a designee, with members from state agencies and representatives appointed by specified state officials and groups.
  • The task force could audit any reverse vending machine and consult organizations, government entities, or people it considers needed for its report.
  • The report would cover bottle-deposit laws, penalties, enforcement, fraud’s fiscal effects, agency coordination, public outreach, prevention, and possible legislation.

The resolution was introduced and referred to a committee on January 29, 2026. It remains in committee; the supplied history does not name the committee or record a vote.

What it means for you#

  • New York City residents and businesses: This resolution itself creates no new rules, duties, refunds, penalties, or enforcement powers.
  • If the state passes A.3469: The task force described in the resolution could examine reverse vending machines and consult with people or organizations. The resolution does not say how audits would work or require any particular business to take part.
  • Bottle-deposit businesses and redemption centers: The resolution calls for a study and recommendations, not changes to deposit amounts, refund rules, or existing penalties.

Money#

No cost estimate is given for the proposed state task force or this Council resolution.

  • The resolution does not specify new New York City spending.
  • It cites an estimate of tens to hundreds of millions of dollars in annual state revenue losses from fraud; this is a claim in the resolution, not a cost estimate for A.3469.

What is unclear#

  • The text of state bill A.3469 was not supplied, so its full provisions cannot be checked against the resolution’s description.
  • The resolution does not give a task-force deadline, audit procedures, or how its members would be paid.
  • The resolution does not explain what would happen after the task force makes its recommendations.

Case for#

  • The Council’s resolution says fraud may cause losses to state revenue and make redemption centers refund deposits on containers for which no deposit was collected.
  • The resolution argues that a task force could study enforcement, coordination among agencies, and prevention, then give state lawmakers recommendations.

Case against#

  • The resolution proposes a study and report; it does not itself change enforcement or bottle-deposit rules. Its effect would depend on later state action.
  • The resolution does not specify a report deadline or explain how recommendations would be put into practice. Without A.3469’s text, it is unclear whether that bill supplies these details.