Requiring police officers to maintain liability insurance (S.3515/A.2220)

Summary#

Res. 0306-2026 is a nonbinding resolution, sponsored by Council Member Nantasha M. Williams, asking the New York State Legislature to pass and the Governor to sign S.3515/A.2220. The resolution says that state bill would require police officers to maintain liability insurance and change state rules on defense and indemnification (who pays for legal defense and liability). Its stated goal is to improve accountability and public safety and reduce costs to local governments; this resolution itself does not change city law or require anyone to buy insurance.

  • The resolution calls on the State Legislature and Governor to act; it does not bind them.
  • As described in the resolution, the state bill would require police officers to maintain insurance during their employment, with employers paying the policy’s base rate.
  • The resolution says the state bill would also exclude police officers and peace officers from certain state defense and indemnification provisions. The state bill text was not provided, so those details cannot be checked here.
  • The resolution was introduced and referred to committee on February 12, 2026. The latest history provided shows it waiting in committee.

What it means for you#

  • Police officers and peace officers: This resolution creates no insurance duty. If the state bill described in it became law, police officers would have to maintain insurance; the resolution says employers would cover the base rate.
  • Police employers and New York City taxpayers: The resolution does not change who pays claims. Its stated aim is to shift some responsibility for lawsuit costs to insurers and officers, but it does not establish that this would happen or save money.
  • New Yorkers: The resolution asks state officials to act. It does not directly change police conduct rules, residents’ rights, or how claims are handled.

Money#

No publicly available information on the cost of the proposed state requirement is included in the supplied material.

  • The resolution says employers would pay the insurance policy’s base rate, but gives no estimate of that cost or who would pay any amount above the base rate.
  • The resolution cites New York City Comptroller figures showing NYPD tort-claim settlements and judgments of $239.1 million in fiscal year 2022 and $266.7 million in fiscal year 2023. Those figures describe existing payouts, not the cost or savings from the proposed insurance requirement.

What is unclear#

  • The state bill text is not provided, so its exact coverage rules, insurance requirements, and changes to indemnification cannot be verified.
  • The resolution does not say how coverage would be set, who would pay costs above the base rate, or what would happen if an officer could not obtain insurance.
  • It does not explain how insurance would affect existing claims, legal defenses, or payments by the City and other employers.

Case for#

  • The resolution argues that insurance could make insurers and officers responsible for lawsuit payouts, reducing the burden on local governments.
  • It cites Comptroller figures showing higher NYPD tort-claim payouts in fiscal year 2023 than in fiscal year 2022. If insurance shifted some of those costs away from public budgets, that could be seen as a reason to support the proposal.
  • The resolution says insurance could improve police conduct and accountability. It does not provide evidence that the proposed requirement would produce those results.

Case against#

  • One concern is that the resolution gives no estimate of the insurance cost to employers or explains who would pay costs beyond the base rate.
  • It is unclear how the proposed insurance requirement would affect legal defense and claim payments, especially because the resolution also describes changes to state indemnification rules.
  • The resolution does not provide details about coverage limits, exceptions, or what would happen if an officer could not obtain coverage.