Disallowing tax exemptions for Article II to XI conversions and establishing related protections to preserve the Mitchell-Lama program

Summary#

Res. 0438-2026 is a New York City Council resolution, sponsored by Gale A. Brewer, asking the New York State Legislature to pass and the Governor to sign legislation about Mitchell-Lama conversions. It would not change city or state law or bind anyone; it is waiting in a Council committee. The stated goal is to preserve Mitchell-Lama housing.

  • The resolution asks the State to disallow tax exemptions for developments converting from Article II (Mitchell-Lama) to Article XI (HDFC).
  • It also calls for related protections: an 80% voting threshold for exits and full compliance with the Martin Act, the State securities law.
  • The resolution says current Article II-to-XI conversions can use a 66⅔% voting threshold and expedited Martin Act procedures. These are claims in the resolution’s text; the requested state legislation is not provided.

What it means for you#

  • Mitchell-Lama residents and shareholders: No rules or rights change if this resolution is adopted. It asks the State to change rules; it does not create a conversion review, vote, or appeal process.
  • New York City residents and taxpayers: The resolution itself does not change tax exemptions or housing availability.
  • New York State: The Council is asking the State Legislature and Governor to act. It does not identify a state bill number.

Money#

No cost estimate or tax-revenue figure is included in the available material.

  • The resolution seeks to disallow tax exemptions for Article II-to-XI conversions, but gives no estimate of affected exemptions or revenue.
  • It does not itself change public spending, taxes, or fees.

What is unclear#

  • The resolution does not provide draft state legislation or specify how the 80% threshold and Martin Act protections would be written.
  • It does not say how any changes would apply to conversions already underway.
  • It is waiting in committee; its passage is uncertain.

Case for#

  • The sponsors argue that public financing and tax abatements were provided in return for affordable housing, and that conversions can raise share prices and reduce affordable housing.
  • They argue that removing tax exemptions, requiring an 80% vote, and ensuring full Martin Act protections would reduce incentives to convert and give residents broader support and more time and information.

Case against#

  • The resolution does not explain how the proposed changes would affect developments already seeking conversion or how the State should handle those cases.
  • One concern is that removing exemptions and changing conversion rules could affect developments differently; the resolution gives no analysis of those effects or of the tax revenue involved.