LU 89 - DY Heights Block 2149, Lots 3, 84, 101, and 104, Block 2156, Lots 22, 33, 35, and 37, Block 2157, Lots 13 and 56, Manhattan, Community District No. 12, Council District No. 10

Summary#

Resolution 522, sponsored by Council Member Linda Lee, approves a real-property-tax exemption for specified lots in Manhattan under state law. It does not amend the City’s code; it approves an exemption with conditions for a housing project. The resolution was adopted on June 11, 2026.

  • The exemption starts on the later of the property’s conveyance to a housing development fund company (HDFC) and HPD’s signing of a regulatory agreement with the owner.
  • The land is exempt, and buildings are exempt only if they exist on the start date. Parts used for business, commercial, or community-facility purposes are excluded.
  • The owner must pay 5% of gross potential rents each year. If it misses HPD’s deadline to provide rent information, the payment becomes the property tax that would otherwise be due.
  • The exemption ends after 40 years at most, or sooner if the regulatory agreement ends or the property no longer has the required HDFC ownership.
  • HPD can end the exemption for specified noncompliance, including unauthorized transfers or construction or demolition without HPD’s written consent. The owner gets at least 60 days to cure the problem after written notice.

What it means for you#

  • The HDFC and property owner: They receive the conditional exemption and must make the annual payments, follow the regulatory agreement, and meet the ownership and other conditions. They cannot also claim other property-tax exemptions or abatements, except for certain benefits for properties occupied by seniors or people with disabilities.
  • HPD: It must enter the regulatory agreement with the owner and may approve certain changes in ownership. It can determine that a violation has occurred and terminate the exemption if the owner does not cure it after notice.
  • Other taxpayers: The resolution may reduce property-tax revenue compared with full taxation, but the amount is not provided. It does not change tax rules for other properties.

Money#

The resolution requires annual payments tied to gross potential rents, but the available material gives no estimate of the project’s tax savings or the City’s revenue impact.

  • The payment is 5% of gross potential rents, including rents for vacant residential, commercial, and community-facility units and certain subsidies. It cannot exceed the property taxes that would otherwise be due.
  • If the owner does not provide the rent information within 365 days of HPD’s request, the payment is the property tax that would otherwise be due.
  • Assessments for local improvements are not exempt. The resolution does not allow refunds for taxes paid before the exemption starts.

What is unclear#

  • The regulatory agreement’s controls and the project’s rent or affordability terms are not included.
  • The materials do not state the project’s current tax bill, expected payments, or estimated effect on City revenue.
  • The exemption’s start date depends on the conveyance and the agreement being completed; neither date is given.

Case for#

  • The resolution provides a defined tax exemption for a project owned by an HDFC, while requiring annual payments based on gross potential rents and setting conditions on ownership and operation.
  • A possible argument for this design is that it offers a tax benefit while retaining payments and HPD oversight. The resolution does not state what project results the benefit is expected to produce.

Case against#

  • One concern is that the City may collect less than it would under ordinary property taxation; the amount cannot be assessed from the available material.
  • The regulatory agreement contains important operating controls, but its terms are not provided, so the public cannot assess the full conditions attached to the exemption.

Votes

The recorded vote on this bill, member by member.

  1. Division No. 439035

    Passed50 members voted

    City Council: Approved, by Council, Res 0522-2026 (Resolution approving an exemption from real property taxes for property located at Block 2149, Lots 3, 84, 101, and 104; Block 2156, Lots 22, 33, 35, and 37; Block 2157, Lots 13 and 56, Manhattan, pursuant to Section 577 of the Private Hous…)

    FOR · 50

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    50For

    • Democratic45
    • Republican5

    0Against