Prohibit health care providers from performing procedures resulting in sterilization without the informed consent of the person being sterilized (S.3357/A.1582)

Summary#

Res. 0623-2026 is a nonbinding New York City Council resolution, not a local law. Prime sponsor Shahana K. Hanif asks the New York State Legislature to pass, and the Governor to sign, S.3357/A.1582, which the resolution says would amend the State Public Health Law. The resolution’s stated goal is to prevent sterilization without the person’s informed consent.

  • As described in the resolution, the state bill would bar health care providers from sterilizing someone based on a guardian’s, health care proxy’s, or other third party’s consent.
  • It would require providers to give needed information and accommodations, allow voluntary supported decision-making, and bar procedures if the provider believes the person cannot consent even with support. The resolution describes an exception for procedures needed to preserve life or prevent serious physical harm.

What it means for you#

  • New York City residents and providers: This resolution would not change anyone’s rights or duties. It asks state officials to act; it does not bind them.
  • People considering sterilization and their providers: If the state bill passed as described, the person’s own informed consent would be required, subject to the stated medical exception. The bill would also set rules about support, capacity, and disability.

Money#

No publicly available information on costs.

What is unclear#

  • The text of S.3357/A.1582 is not supplied, so its exact wording and details cannot be checked against the resolution’s description.
  • The resolution says current state law allows courts to authorize sterilization through substituted consent; the relevant state law text is not supplied to verify that account.
  • The resolution is in committee after introduction on September 10, 2026. Its later path and whether the state bill will pass are unknown.

Case for#

  • The resolution’s sponsors argue that requiring the person’s own informed consent would protect people from coerced sterilization and support their control over decisions about their bodies.
  • The resolution says supporters could help a person understand the procedure and communicate a choice, without deciding for them.

Case against#

  • One concern is that, as described, a provider could not perform the procedure if they believe the person cannot consent even with support. The resolution does not explain how that judgment would be made or reviewed.
  • The resolution does not explain how the medical exception would be applied in practice.