Regents Would Control Scholarship Tax Credit

Summary#

S10734 would amend New York’s Education Law and Tax Law; the supplied text gives no separate short title. It would make the Board of Regents the only state entity allowed to decide whether New York participates in the federal scholarship tax credit program under 26 U.S.C. § 25F, and to decide which organizations qualify. The bill’s stated goal is to clarify who has that authority.

  • The Board of Regents would be the only state entity allowed to make the state’s participation election and provide the state’s list of qualified scholarship-granting organizations to the U.S. Treasury.
  • Any election made by another state officer or entity would be void.
  • The Tax Commissioner could not elect for the state or take action to implement an election unless the Board of Regents had first elected to participate.
  • The Board may make rules and take other measures to carry out the act; the bill does not require it to do so.
  • The bill would take effect immediately, but apply to tax years starting on or after January 1, 2028. It has been introduced and referred to the Senate Rules Committee; it is not law.

What it means for you#

  • State government: The Board of Regents would hold the state’s decision-making authority over participation and the list of qualified organizations. The Tax Commissioner’s authority to act would depend on the Board’s election.
  • Scholarship-granting organizations: The Board would decide which organizations qualify for the state’s list. The bill does not set qualification standards or create an application process.
  • Taxpayers, students, and families: The bill would not itself create scholarships, provide tax benefits, or set who may receive aid. It could affect whether the state participates in the federal program, but the Board would not be required to opt in.
  • The supplied materials do not include the current versions of the Education Law or Tax Law, so the current allocation of authority cannot be verified.

Money#

No publicly available information.

  • The bill gives the Board authority to make rules and take other measures, but does not require new spending or staffing or provide a cost estimate.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not define what makes an organization a “qualified scholarship granting organization” or set criteria for the Board’s decisions.
  • It does not specify how the Board would decide whether to participate, when it would make that decision, or whether it must consult anyone.
  • It does not set a process for organizations to seek qualification or challenge a decision.
  • The supplied materials do not explain how the bill’s rules would interact with the current state laws or the federal program’s requirements.
  • The bill does not say what happens if the Board has not made an election by the start of a tax year.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that one state body would clearly control both the participation decision and the list of qualified organizations.
  • Giving the Board of Regents both roles could make it easier to keep the state’s participation decision and its list of organizations aligned.
  • The bill expressly prevents another state entity’s election from taking effect, which could avoid competing claims of authority.

Case against#

  • One concern is that the bill concentrates the participation and qualification decisions in one body without setting decision criteria or a process.
  • It is unclear how organizations or affected residents could understand or challenge the Board’s decisions.
  • The Board may choose not to participate; the bill does not require an election or ensure the program will operate in New York.