Pattern misconduct reviews misdemeanor cases

Summary#

S-10735, the Pattern Misconduct Case Review Act, would amend an existing provision of New York’s Executive Law. Its apparent aim is to connect findings of law-enforcement misconduct with individual reviews of certain misdemeanor cases. The bill is introduced and has not become law.

  • A covered agency’s head would have to refer complaints to the Attorney General’s law enforcement misconduct investigative office if the office receives at least five complaints from at least five people, about at least five separate incidents involving one officer or employee within two years.
  • The office would have to investigate those complaints to determine whether the officer or employee engaged in a pattern or practice of misconduct, excessive force, or dishonesty.
  • If the office makes such a finding, it would have to provide its findings to each district attorney whose jurisdiction may include a misdemeanor matter in which the officer or employee materially participated.
  • A district attorney would have to review each identified misdemeanor matter within 60 days after receiving the findings or a qualifying request. The review must be individualized and end with a written determination about whether dismissal, modification, consent to vacatur (setting aside a conviction), further investigation, or no further action is warranted.
  • Within 60 days after making that determination, the district attorney would have to send it to the office for website publication and make it available to the affected defendant and defence counsel, subject to legally required redactions or withholding.

What it means for you#

  • People with affected misdemeanor cases or convictions: Their matter would have to receive an individualized review if it is identified under the bill’s process. The bill does not require a case to be dismissed or a conviction to be vacated.
  • District attorneys: They would have to conduct the reviews, make written determinations, and send those determinations for publication and to the affected defendant and defence counsel.
  • Covered agencies and their employees: An agency head would have to refer complaints once the stated number, people, incidents, and two-year period are met. The bill does not itself set an employment penalty for an officer or employee.
  • The Attorney General’s office: The existing investigative office would investigate the complaints and, if it finds a pattern or practice, send findings to relevant district attorneys. The bill does not create a new independent agency.
  • The bill says these steps do not replace other civil, criminal, administrative, or other proceedings. It also says they do not limit a court’s authority or any other legal rights or remedies.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The bill would assign duties to the investigative office and district attorneys, but the material gives no estimate of staffing needs or costs.
  • No fiscal note, funding source, or appropriation is provided.

What is unclear#

  • The current version of the Executive Law provision being amended was not supplied. I cannot verify which parts of the proposed wording are new and which may already be law.
  • The supplied text does not define “covered agency” or “qualifying request,” or say who may make such a request and what it must contain.
  • It does not explain how the office identifies the misdemeanor matters for review, or how defendants would learn that a review is available.
  • The bill does not set out a process for challenging a determination or a deadline for the review itself beyond the 60-day period to issue the determination.
  • The bill would take effect immediately if enacted, but does not explain how pending cases or convictions would be handled.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that a finding of repeated misconduct, excessive force, or dishonesty should prompt a review of misdemeanor matters in which the officer or employee materially participated.
  • Requiring an individualized review could allow district attorneys to consider each matter on its own facts rather than automatically dismissing or vacating cases.
  • Written determinations and publication could make the review process more visible, while the bill preserves courts’ authority and other legal rights.

Case against#

  • The complaint threshold is specific and may leave cases outside the process, including matters that do not meet the required numbers of people, incidents, and complaints within two years.
  • The bill focuses on misdemeanor matters. It does not require review of felony matters.
  • The bill does not explain who can make a “qualifying request” or how cases are selected, leaving important parts of the process unclear.
  • The bill adds duties for the investigative office and district attorneys without stating the resources or funding available to carry them out.