Summary#
S-10740 would amend New York’s Social Services Law and Real Property Actions and Proceedings Law to set rules for discharge from supportive housing and eviction proceedings involving its tenants. Its stated goal is to establish supportive-housing procedures; the bill does not guarantee any particular outcome. It was introduced and referred to the Senate Rules Committee, so it is not law; if enacted, it would take effect 90 days later.
- A tenant receiving services through a state- or city-contracted supportive-housing program could be discharged only if known to be deceased, if the contracting agency certifies the tenant cannot be located to verify eligibility, or if the tenant voluntarily leaves or transfers.
- Contracting agencies would have to create notice and appeal processes, track exits in databases, and conduct a good-faith search of at least 90 days before certifying that a tenant cannot be located. Providers would have to report deaths within 10 days.
- Providers could start eviction cases for specified reasons: unpaid tenant rent not caused by a lapse in eligible government support; repeated, severe or outrageous conduct creating a health or safety hazard; or reasonable grounds to believe the tenant no longer uses the unit as a primary residence. Extra steps would apply, including efforts to resolve problems and written notice.
- Eviction or failure to take part in offered services would not be grounds to discharge someone from the program. An eviction case would still require a full court hearing.
- A new petition rule would require landlords or providers bringing covered cases to identify the tenant’s services, subsidies, governing rules and required notices. A petition missing required information would be defective.
What it means for you#
- Supportive-housing tenants: You would have a right to appeal an agency determination within 12 months. A discharge under appeal would be stayed until the agency or a court resolves it. You could bring an advocate to required meetings. In rent cases, the provider would have to give a detailed rent statement and make at least three service-intervention attempts before seeking relief.
- Tenants facing eviction over conduct: Providers would have to give detailed notice, investigate objections, arrange a meeting, and retain a licensed mental-health professional to assess whether known health or mental-health disability is related to the conduct and whether support or accommodations could address it. Special assessment and service steps apply to alleged domestic-violence incidents.
- Providers and landlords: They would have to follow the bill’s notices, meetings, documentation, and assistance requirements before filing covered eviction cases. They could not start a rent case while a tenant is cooperating or willing to cooperate with efforts to obtain an arrears grant.
- Contracting agencies: They would have to establish appeal processes, create and maintain exit records, and issue a stay of legal action in certain cases where required procedures were not followed.
- Tenants generally: The bill does not make eviction impossible. It sets conditions and procedures for starting cases and requires a court hearing before eviction or termination of tenancy.
Money#
No cost estimate is included in the available material.
- The bill would require agency staff time for appeals, searches, databases, forms and case review; it gives no staffing or cost estimate.
- Providers would have to pay for a licensed mental-health professional in certain conduct cases and provide other required assistance; the bill gives no estimate.
- The bill does not specify new funding or an appropriation.
What is unclear#
- The supplied material does not include the current versions of the amended laws, so what protections already exist and how much this bill changes them cannot be verified.
- The bill does not explain how agencies should decide whether someone is “known” to be deceased, cannot be located, or has voluntarily left.
- It uses “division” for the office a tenant should contact during a search, but does not identify or define that division.
- It does not set out all details of the appeal process, such as deadlines for agency decisions or how a tenant learns of a discharge determination.
- The bill does not explain how its ban on involuntary transfer or removal from an apartment relates to the eviction cases it permits.
Case for#
- The bill appears intended to prevent tenants from losing program status for being evicted or not taking part in services, while giving them a way to challenge discharge.
- Detailed rent statements, meetings, investigation of objections and direct assistance could help identify errors or address arrears before a case is filed.
- Notice, documentation and court-hearing requirements could make the reasons and steps behind an eviction easier to examine.
- The search and exit records could help agencies distinguish a voluntary move from a tenant who cannot be found.
Case against#
- The required steps could be costly and time-consuming for providers and agencies; the bill gives no funding or cost estimate.
- Terms such as “reasonable effort,” “repeated, severe or outrageous” conduct, and “reasonable grounds” are not defined in the bill, which could leave room for disagreement.
- The bill requires tenant signatures on objection forms and says unsigned forms are invalid, but does not explain what happens if a tenant cannot or will not sign.
- The relationship between the ban on involuntary removal from an apartment and the eviction process is unclear. That could make the rules difficult to apply consistently.