Summary#
S-10737 would amend New York’s General Municipal Law, Environmental Conservation Law and Highway Law, and add four new sections to the General Municipal Law. It aims to speed approval and permitting for some building and housing projects; it is introduced and is not law, so passage is uncertain.
- Municipalities would have to grant certain zoning modifications of up to 15% within 10 days if stated conditions are met. For modifications over 5%, the bill also requires notice and allows 14 days for objections; an objection sends the request to the zoning board of appeals.
- Municipalities could limit repeat inspections after certain special inspections, and would have to waive or refund building permit fees if an official or municipality-hired inspector rejects work explicitly approved in the plans.
- A city, town or village could create a program allowing permits based on a licensed architect’s or engineer’s certification, with rules for appeals, random audits and referrals for wrongdoing or negligence. The bill text does not give developers a general power to hire third-party inspectors, despite the title’s description.
- Planning and zoning boards would have to begin considering certain residential requests within 60 days or the request would be automatically approved. Building permits would be valid for at least two years for projects under 100 units and four years for projects over 100 units.
- Some housing projects would be exempt from specified county or regional reviews. Wetland boundary delineations would last 15 years instead of five.
- For housing projects, the state Department of Transportation could not require review if no work is within a state highway right of way. For permits it does require, the bill sets response and decision deadlines, with approval deemed if the department does not approve or deny within six weeks.
What it means for you#
- Developers and applicants: Some qualifying zoning requests and permits could move faster. Applicants would pay the cost of required zoning notices. The bill does not say what happens if a highway permit application is still awaiting information when the six-week deadline arrives.
- Neighbors: For zoning modifications over 5%, abutting property owners would get mailed notice, and objections could send the request to a hearing. Modifications of 5% or less would not require public notice under this bill.
- Municipalities and boards: Municipalities would have to follow the inspection, refund and permit-timing rules. They could choose whether to set up the architect-or-engineer certification program. Boards face a 60-day deadline for certain residential requests.
- People affected by county or regional review: The bill exempts specified variances, special permits and small residential projects from certain reviews; it defines small projects as those disturbing less than five acres. It also allows a person alleging particularized harm to seek court review of certain decisions under the county-review law.
- Wetland landowners and others seeking a boundary delineation: A delineation would remain effective for 15 years rather than five.
- The bill does not itself guarantee that a project will be built, change taxes, or create a general right to a building permit.
Money#
No cost estimate is provided in the supplied material.
- Applicants would pay for zoning notices required by the bill.
- Municipalities could face costs to run the optional certification program and to waive or refund permit fees in the specified inspection situation. The bill gives no cost or staffing estimate.
- The bill does not state a funding source for these duties.
What is unclear#
- The zoning section requires a grant within 10 days, but also gives 14 days for objections on requests over 5%. It does not explain how those deadlines fit together.
- “Residential action” and what it means for a board to “begin to consider” a request are not defined. The bill also does not set out a full process for the 60-day deadline.
- The permit-duration rules cover projects under and over 100 units, but do not specify a duration for a project of exactly 100 units.
- The highway section does not explain how the six-week clock works after a request for more information.
- The bill’s title refers to a developer hiring an approved third-party inspector, but the supplied bill text does not set out that authority.
- The current versions of the amended laws were not supplied. Aside from the stated change in wetland-delineation duration, the available text does not allow a full check of what the amendments change compared with current law.
Case for#
- A possible argument for the bill is that clear deadlines and automatic approval rules could reduce delays for some housing requests and permits.
- Limiting repeat inspections of the same work could avoid duplicated inspections, while keeping exceptions for deficiencies, applicant requests and cases where the municipality covers the fees.
- Longer-lasting wetland delineations could reduce how often boundaries need to be established again.
Case against#
- Automatic approvals and shorter review periods could limit time for municipal review. The bill does not explain how boards should handle the deadline when a request needs more work.
- The zoning notice and objection period conflicts with the 10-day grant requirement, making the process uncertain.
- The bill does not provide estimates for the costs of staffing and administering the new duties, or of any optional certification program.
- The mismatch between the title’s third-party-inspector description and the bill text could leave applicants and municipalities unsure what inspection option is actually authorized.