Home equity investment loans regulated

Summary#

The Home Equity Investment Loan Act is an introduced bill, not current law. It would create a new article in Chapter 53 and amend North Carolina mortgage and lending laws to treat covered home equity investment loans as residential mortgage loans. Its stated goal is to regulate these loans and add consumer protections.

  • It would cover arrangements that advance funds to a homeowner in return for a payment tied to the home’s value, equity, appreciation, or sale proceeds, including arrangements structured to evade the law. It excludes transactions made, insured, guaranteed, or administered by government agencies and certain government-sponsored entities.
  • The Commissioner of Banks would administer the rules. Companies making, brokering, or servicing these loans would need mortgage-business authority and a separate authorization to make them. A purchaser or assignee would be subject to the law when it owns, holds, services, collects, or enforces a loan, but buying a loan alone would not require that separate authorization.
  • A homeowner’s total payment would be limited to funds advanced, certain unreimbursed protective advances, and one contractually elected value-based amount: up to 10% of the increase in the home’s value, or up to 10% of its value at payment. That value-based amount could not be collected unless the loan had been outstanding for at least 24 months.
  • Companies would have to provide advance disclosures, pay closing costs and the homeowner’s required attorney and housing-counseling costs, and provide annual account statements. The bill also sets limits on when payment can be triggered, allows penalty-free prepayment, bars deficiency judgments, and requires a refinance offer in specified circumstances.
  • The Commissioner could impose civil penalties of up to $5,000 per violation, and violations would count as unfair or deceptive acts or practices. Most provisions are proposed to apply to applications made on or after October 1, 2026; some licensing and rulemaking provisions would take effect when the bill becomes law.

What it means for you#

  • Homeowners: The bill would require an attorney you select and approved housing counseling before closing; the company must pay their actual and reasonable costs. You would receive disclosures at least 20 business days before closing, in English and in other languages used to explain or market the loan to you.
  • Homeowners: You could prepay without a penalty. If the loan becomes due and you tell the company you cannot pay without selling the home, the company must offer a refinance with a fixed rate no higher than the stated average prime offer rate, substantially equal monthly principal-and-interest payments over at least 10 years, and no points, origination fee, or prepayment penalty. The bill does not say you must accept that offer.
  • Homeowners: The company’s only remedy after the loan is due would be enforcement against the property, not a deficiency judgment against you. The loan could become due at scheduled maturity, a voluntary transfer of title, specified uncured failures to pay property charges or address waste, or certain circumstances after the homeowner’s death.
  • Companies and loan holders: Companies would have to follow the bill’s payment limits, disclosures, notice and cure rules, and other duties. A purchaser or assignee would also be subject to the homeowner’s claims, defenses, setoff, and recoupment rights against earlier parties.
  • Mortgage borrowers: The bill would add a state rule against mandatory arbitration terms in covered mortgage transactions only to the extent those terms are prohibited by the cited federal law or regulation. It also adds a reference to that state rule in the law on bank equity lines of credit.

Money#

No public cost estimate is provided; the bill authorizes fees and penalties and requires companies to cover specified costs.

  • A company would pay a $500 application fee and a $250 annual renewal fee for authorization. It could not pass those fees on to the homeowner as loan costs.
  • Companies would pay all closing costs, including the required attorney and housing-counseling costs.
  • The Commissioner could impose a penalty of up to $5,000 for each violation. The bill provides no estimate of fee revenue, penalty revenue, or public costs for administration, staffing, or rulemaking.

What is unclear#

  • The current versions of the statutes being amended were not provided. I could not verify which protections already apply or precisely what each amendment would change from current law.
  • The bill leaves some terms and practical standards unclear, including what counts as “actual and reasonable” costs and how counselor approval, refinance offers, and some valuation disagreements would work in practice.
  • The Commissioner may make rules, but the bill does not set application-processing timelines, an appeal process for authorization decisions, or reporting requirements.
  • The bill does not explain how its rules would interact with other existing programs or protections that might apply to a particular loan.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that these arrangements can tie a homeowner’s payment to the home’s future value while putting the home at risk of foreclosure. Treating them as residential mortgage loans would bring them under state mortgage laws.
  • The payment formula, appraisal rules, and required examples could make the potential cost easier to assess before a homeowner agrees.
  • Requiring independent legal advice and housing counseling, paid for by the company, could help homeowners understand the contract without having to pay those required costs themselves.
  • Limits on payment triggers, deficiency judgments, and required notice and cure periods could give homeowners more protection if they cannot pay when the loan comes due.

Case against#

  • The bill would impose detailed costs and duties on companies, including authorization fees, counseling and attorney costs, and a limit on the value-based payment. The bill provides no estimate of how those requirements might affect loan availability or terms.
  • A refinance offer is required in specified cases, but the bill does not set out detailed eligibility or affordability standards for that offer. The offer therefore may not resolve every homeowner’s difficulty paying.
  • The Commissioner would have to implement and enforce a new set of rules, but the bill gives no estimate of the staff or resources needed.
  • The bill uses broad coverage language, including arrangements “structured to evade” the law, while leaving some terms and implementation details to future rules. That could make some requirements harder to predict until rules or decisions clarify them.