Constitutional ethics: recusal and disclosures for justices

Summary#

“Const. Amend./Supreme Court Ethics” would propose amendments to the North Carolina Constitution. It would set recusal rules for Supreme Court justices and require them to report certain financial activity and travel; its stated goal is to require recusal in certain cases and financial disclosure. The bill is introduced and is not law.

  • A justice would have to disqualify themself from a case in listed situations, unless doing so would prevent a Supreme Court quorum (enough justices to act).
  • Those situations include certain financial or personal interests involving the justice, a spouse, or specified relatives; and a case challenging a law the justice sponsored as a legislator.
  • A justice would have to report purchases or sales worth at least $10,000, income other than the justice’s state salary, and who sponsored or funded the justice’s travel.
  • Reports would go to the State Ethics Commission or a successor entity. The bill does not create a new independent agency.
  • If the bill becomes law, the amendment would go to voters at the November 3, 2026 general election. It would take effect upon certification if a majority of votes cast on it are in favor.

What it means for you#

  • Supreme Court justices: They would have to follow the listed recusal rules and make the specified disclosures in addition to disclosures already required by law.
  • People and organizations with cases before the Court: The rules could affect whether a justice takes part in a case. The bill does not set out a process for requesting or deciding recusal.
  • Voters: If the bill becomes law, voters would decide whether to approve the constitutional amendment. It would not take effect if a majority of votes cast are against it.
  • General public: The bill does not directly change individual rights, taxes, or benefits. It requires disclosures to the Ethics Commission but does not say whether those records would be public.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The bill directs the Ethics Commission or a successor entity to receive disclosures, but gives no estimate of staffing, administrative, or election costs.
  • The required reporting could take staff time at the Commission; the bill does not say how much. (This is an inference.)
  • The bill does not set fees or fines.

What is unclear#

  • The current North Carolina Constitution is not supplied, so it is not possible to verify which parts of the rewritten section already exist and which would be new.
  • The bill does not define “other interest” or explain how a justice should determine whether an interest could be substantially affected by a case.
  • It does not set out how recusal decisions are made, who can challenge them, or what happens if recusal would prevent a quorum.
  • It does not say whether financial and travel disclosures would be public, or specify penalties for failing to disclose.
  • The amendment would take effect upon certification of voter approval, but the bill gives no details about how the proposed reporting rules would be administered.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to set constitutional rules for when a justice must step aside from a case involving certain personal or financial interests.
  • Requiring reports of significant transactions, outside income, and travel sponsors could give the Ethics Commission information about justices’ financial ties and travel.
  • Putting the rules in the Constitution could make them less dependent on ordinary law. The bill does not explain how they would interact with existing disclosure requirements.

Case against#

  • The bill allows a justice to remain in a case if disqualification would prevent a quorum, even when a listed reason for disqualification applies.
  • Terms such as “other interest” are not defined, and the bill does not provide a process for resolving disagreements about whether recusal is required.
  • The bill does not specify penalties, public access to disclosures, or how the Ethics Commission would check them.
  • The reporting duties could require additional administrative work, but the bill provides no cost estimate or funding.