Judicial discipline hearings go public

Summary#

H-1236, “Const. Amend./Judicial Standards Commission,” would amend the North Carolina Constitution and statutes governing the existing Judicial Standards Commission. It would put the Commission’s membership in the Constitution and make disciplinary hearings and certain records public; its stated goal is fair, transparent, and nonpartisan oversight. The bill is introduced and is not law.

  • Voters would decide the constitutional amendment at the November 3, 2026, general election. It would take effect upon certification if approved.
  • The amendment would set a 15-member Commission: five judges appointed by the Chief Justice, five licensed attorneys appointed by officers of the North Carolina State Bar, and five residents who are neither lawyers nor judges, appointed by the Governor.
  • If voters approve the amendment, the statutory changes would take effect January 1, 2027. They would make disciplinary hearings public and make charges, answers, other pleadings, recommendations, and supporting records public at the specified stages.
  • The number of Commission members who must agree to recommend a public reprimand, censure, suspension, or removal would rise from five to eight.
  • The bill does not create the Commission. It does not make every complaint or investigation public: the text keeps proceedings confidential unless the judge waives confidentiality or a stated disclosure rule applies.

What it means for you#

  • Voters: You would vote on whether to add the Commission and its membership rules to the Constitution.
  • Judges facing discipline: If the changes take effect, disciplinary hearings would be public. After the Commission decides to start disciplinary proceedings, the charges, the judge’s answer, other pleadings, and the Commission’s recommendation and supporting record would be public. The Supreme Court would still decide whether to impose a public reprimand, censure, suspension, or removal, and a majority of justices voting would have to agree.
  • Public: You would have access to specified disciplinary proceedings and records. The bill does not make all complaints or investigations public.
  • Judges, attorneys, and the public: The proposed constitutional membership would give appointment roles to the Chief Justice, State Bar officers, and Governor. The bill does not directly change the public’s other rights or services.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The State Board of Elections would certify the referendum results, and the election would be conducted under state election laws. The bill gives no cost estimate.
  • The bill does not state a Commission staffing level, provide a funding amount, or estimate the cost of holding public hearings or providing public records.

What is unclear#

  • The supplied text includes existing statutory membership rules that differ from the proposed constitutional membership. It does not clearly explain how those statutory rules would fit with the new constitutional rules.
  • The bill does not explain what records would be withheld or redacted, or how privacy concerns would be handled once records become public.
  • It does not set detailed rules for how hearings would be run or when records must be released.
  • “Officers” of the State Bar is not further defined in the supplied text.
  • The available material does not include the full current law, so the statutory changes could not be checked independently against the complete law now in force.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to make judicial discipline more open to the public, rather than keeping hearings and key records confidential.
  • A possible argument for the constitutional membership rules is that they give judges, attorneys, and non-lawyer citizens defined roles in the Commission.
  • Public access to charges, responses, and recommendations could let people see more of the basis for disciplinary decisions.

Case against#

  • One concern is that charges and a judge’s response would become public before the Supreme Court makes a final decision, which could expose allegations that do not lead to a sanction.
  • The bill does not clearly resolve the mismatch between the proposed constitutional membership and the membership rules shown in the statutory text.
  • Raising the agreement needed for a recommendation from five members to eight could make recommendations harder to issue; the bill does not explain why that threshold is chosen.
  • The bill states a goal of nonpartisan proceedings, but it does not set out a process or test that guarantees nonpartisanship.