Election audit bill would review procedures

Summary#

“Post-Election Audits by State Auditor” would amend North Carolina’s General Statutes by adding a new section on audits of general elections. Its stated aim is to require the State Auditor to audit election procedures; the bill is introduced and is not law.

  • After each general election is certified, the Auditor must choose counties for audits. The Auditor decides how many and which counties, but every county board of elections must be audited within a “reasonable time frame.”
  • The Auditor may examine voter rolls, voting equipment tests and storage, ballot and poll-book records, chain of custody, absentee and provisional ballots, voter contact and assistance, and other concerns found during the audit. The bill does not require every listed area to be examined in every audit.
  • The State Board of Elections, county boards of elections, and the Division of Motor Vehicles must provide ready access to materials, equipment, personnel, or software needed for the audits. Election officials may be present when needed to preserve chain of custody.
  • The Auditor must issue periodic reports to named state officials and bodies, including the State Board of Elections and the Joint Legislative Elections Oversight Committee. Reports must say which areas were examined and the findings; county boards discussed must have a chance to comment before submission. Reports must be posted prominently online, subject to confidentiality laws.
  • If the Auditor believes audit information may be evidence of a legal violation, the Auditor must refer it under an existing law. If an audit finds an error, inefficiency, or vulnerability, the county board must send the Auditor and other named bodies a report outlining a plan to fix it.
  • The audits would be in addition to audits under existing election law. They could not be used as grounds to challenge an election’s final result.

What it means for you#

  • County election boards: Must provide access for audits and, if an audit finds an error, inefficiency, or vulnerability, report a plan to address it. The bill does not expressly require the board to carry out that plan.
  • State Auditor and election agencies: The Auditor would have a new audit duty and discretion over county selection and audit numbers. The State Board of Elections and DMV would have to provide access to needed resources.
  • Voters: The bill does not directly change voting rules, eligibility, ballot counting, or election results. It creates additional oversight after certification, not a process to overturn results.
  • General public: Audit reports and supplementary materials must be posted online, but confidentiality laws still apply.

Money#

The bill requires audits and access to staff and other resources, but the supplied material gives no cost estimate.

  • No appropriation, fee, fine, or tax change is specified.
  • The bill does not say how many staff hours, audits, or other resources will be needed, or what they will cost.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not define “reasonable time frame” or say how often “periodic” reports must be issued.
  • It does not set county-selection criteria, audit methods, or a minimum number of audits per year.
  • It does not say how findings will be followed up or what happens if a county does not submit a plan.
  • The bill refers to other laws for access and referrals, but those laws were not supplied, so their exact procedures could not be checked.
  • The bill says the audits add to existing audits, but the materials do not show how the new audits would coordinate with current audit procedures.
  • The current text of the amended law was not supplied, so the existing powers and procedures of the State Auditor could not be compared in full.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that auditing election systems and controls after certification could identify weaknesses without disrupting the certified result.
  • The listed areas cover records, equipment, ballot handling, and voter assistance, giving the Auditor a broad set of subjects to examine.
  • Public reports and county comments could make findings visible while giving local boards a chance to respond.
  • Requiring a county to report a plan after a problem is found could create a documented next step.

Case against#

  • The Auditor controls which counties and how many are audited, while the bill does not set selection criteria or a minimum pace beyond auditing every county within a “reasonable time frame.”
  • The Auditor may examine the listed subjects but is not required to examine all of them, and the bill does not set a common audit method.
  • The bill requires a plan report after a problem is found but does not clearly require the county to carry out the plan or set a deadline.
  • The bill does not specify the staffing or cost needed for statewide audits, or how the new work would fit with existing audits.