Legislature to study existing laws before bills

Summary#

HCR 3010 is a concurrent resolution, not a bill that amends an existing law. It asks the Legislative Management to consider studying how lawmakers should review existing laws and regulations when proposing new laws; its stated goal is to avoid duplication and consider effects on existing programs. The supplied status says it has passed the House, but does not show passage by the Senate.

  • If adopted, the resolution would direct Legislative Management to consider whether to study this topic. It does not require that the study be carried out.
  • The resolution says the topic should include existing federal and state regulations and how proposed laws could affect those regulations and regulated programs.
  • It directs Legislative Management to report findings and recommendations, and any legislation needed to carry them out, to the Seventieth Legislative Assembly.

What it means for you#

  • Legislative Management: If the resolution is adopted, it would be asked to consider studying the topic and report findings and recommendations. The resolution does not set out how a study would be done.
  • Lawmakers and the public: The resolution does not itself require lawmakers to review existing law before proposing a bill, change any law, or create a new public service.
  • Everyone else: It creates no direct rights, duties, fees, fines, or benefits.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The resolution gives no spending amount and does not specify funding or staffing for a study.

What is unclear#

  • Whether Legislative Management would decide to conduct the study.
  • What questions, laws, or regulations a study would cover, and how it would be carried out.
  • Whether the study would include public input or other oversight; the resolution does not say.
  • The resolution does not set out a timetable beyond directing a report to the Seventieth Legislative Assembly.

Case for#

  • A review could help lawmakers identify when a proposal duplicates existing law, a concern the resolution specifically raises.
  • Considering federal and state regulations could help lawmakers understand how a new state law might affect existing rules and regulated programs.
  • A report could recommend legislation if the study finds changes are needed.

Case against#

  • The resolution does not require the study itself, so the topic may not receive a full review.
  • It does not establish a review process for future bills. Even if adopted, it would not by itself require lawmakers to check existing law when developing proposals.
  • The scope and methods are left open, making it unclear what the study would examine or how useful its recommendations would be.