Study outdated laws for repeal

Summary#

Senate Concurrent Resolution No. 4025 would have asked the Legislative Management to consider studying all state laws for laws that are outdated, unnecessary, or create an undue burden. It does not amend state law or require the study itself; it was not adopted, so it creates no current duty. Its stated goal was to identify laws that might be appropriate to repeal.

  • The Legislative Management would have been asked to consider whether to study all state laws.
  • The resolution also says the Legislative Management would report findings and recommendations, with any legislation needed to carry them out, to the Seventieth Legislative Assembly.
  • It sets no review criteria beyond the broad descriptions of laws to identify, and it does not itself repeal or change any law.

What it means for you#

  • North Dakota residents and businesses: The resolution would not directly change your rights, duties, services, or costs. Any law changes would require later legislation.
  • Legislative Management: It would have been asked to consider undertaking a broad review. The resolution does not specify how the review would work.
  • Current status: The resolution failed to be adopted, so it does not require Legislative Management to consider a study or make a report.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The resolution gives no spending amount or staffing requirement. It also does not say whether a study would be done or what resources it might use.

What is unclear#

  • The resolution does not define “outdated,” “unnecessary,” or “undue burden.”
  • It does not set a method, timeline, or scope for examining the laws.
  • It asks Legislative Management to consider studying the laws, but does not say what happens if it decides not to study them. The reporting direction does not explain how it would apply in that case.
  • It does not identify who would take part in the review or how findings would be checked.

Case for#

  • A broad review could identify laws for lawmakers to consider changing or repealing.
  • Asking for recommendations and any needed legislation could give the next Assembly specific proposals to consider.
  • The resolution would leave decisions about changing laws to the Legislature rather than repealing laws automatically.

Case against#

  • The key standards are undefined, so the resolution does not show how reviewers would decide which laws are outdated, unnecessary, or burdensome.
  • The resolution does not require the study itself. Even if adopted, the review might not happen.
  • Reviewing all state laws could require staff time and resources, but the resolution gives no estimate or plan for those costs.