Resolution urges federal action on statehood

Summary#

Senate Concurrent Resolution 4009 is a North Dakota resolution, not a bill amending state law. It would express support for admitting Washington, D.C. as a state and urge Congress and the President to act; that is its stated goal, not an outcome it can ensure. The resolution failed to adopt, so it did not take effect as an adopted resolution.

  • It would state that the North Dakota Legislature supports D.C. statehood.
  • It would oppose federal actions that interfere with D.C.’s local self-government, including federal changes to or rejection of local actions and limits on spending locally raised tax revenue.
  • It would call on Congress and the President to enact federal legislation granting D.C. statehood.
  • It would direct North Dakota’s Secretary of State to send copies to the President, Vice President, House Speaker, and North Dakota’s congressional delegation.

What it means for you#

  • North Dakota residents: The resolution would not change your state taxes, rights, or services. Because it failed to adopt, the Secretary of State was not given the resolution’s proposed duty to send copies.
  • Washington, D.C. residents: It would not make D.C. a state or change your rights or local government. It would ask federal officials to take that action.
  • Federal officials: The resolution would communicate the North Dakota Legislature’s position, but it would not require Congress or the President to act.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The resolution proposes no appropriation, tax, fee, or benefit.
  • It would direct the Secretary of State to send copies, but the materials do not estimate the cost.

What is unclear#

  • The resolution does not set out the details of a federal statehood law, such as the exact boundaries or other terms. It refers to a boundary proposal approved by D.C. voters but does not include it as an operative rule.
  • It does not explain how to distinguish federal actions that interfere with local self-government from other federal oversight.
  • No estimate is provided for the cost of sending copies.

Case for#

  • The resolution appears intended to support D.C. residents having the same state-level representation and self-government as residents of states.
  • A possible argument for the resolution is that North Dakota can formally urge federal action while leaving the details of statehood legislation to Congress.
  • It would also object to federal limits on D.C.’s control of local decisions and locally raised revenue.

Case against#

  • The resolution would take a position on D.C. statehood without setting out the boundaries or other terms of a statehood plan.
  • One concern is that it opposes a broad range of federal actions affecting D.C. without explaining what federal oversight, if any, should remain.
  • Its direct effect would be to express a position and send copies; it could not itself change D.C.’s status or require federal officials to act.