Term-limit convention stalled

Summary#

SCR-4011 is a North Dakota Senate concurrent resolution, not a law imposing term limits. It would have asked Congress to call an Article V convention limited to proposing a U.S. constitutional amendment setting term limits for House and Senate members; its stated goal was to safeguard accountability and liberty. The resolution failed to pass on second reading, so it did not make North Dakota’s application.

  • If adopted, it would have applied for a convention on congressional term limits and asked that the application count with applications from other states on the same subject toward the two-thirds threshold.
  • It says the application would continue until legislatures in at least two-thirds of the states had applied on that subject. It would not count applications on other subjects.
  • It does not set the number of terms, impose term limits, or itself call a convention.
  • If adopted, it would have directed North Dakota’s Secretary of State to send copies to named federal officials and the state’s congressional delegation.

What it means for you#

  • North Dakota residents: The failed resolution does not directly change your rights, taxes, services, or choice of candidates.
  • People who vote for or serve in Congress: It did not impose term limits or change eligibility to run.
  • North Dakota officials: Because the resolution failed, it did not create the proposed duty for the Secretary of State to send copies.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The resolution includes no appropriation, fee, fine, or estimate for sending copies or other work.

What is unclear#

  • The resolution does not say how many terms a proposed amendment should allow, or how it would treat partial terms or current members.
  • It does not set out how a convention would operate or how its proposed amendment would be handled.
  • It does not explain how applications from other states would be judged to cover the “same subject” or aggregated.
  • The supplied material does not show whether other states have made applications the resolution would seek to aggregate with.

Case for#

  • The resolution’s stated case is that term limits could safeguard members’ accountability to constituents.
  • A possible argument for the approach is that it asks for a convention limited to proposing an amendment on congressional term limits, rather than asking it to address other subjects.
  • The continuing-application and aggregation language is intended to keep North Dakota’s application in effect and count it toward the stated two-thirds threshold.

Case against#

  • The resolution would not itself create term limits; it depends on a convention being called and an amendment being proposed and adopted.
  • It does not specify the limits to be proposed, leaving a central policy choice unanswered.
  • It is unclear how the “same subject” rule would work when combining state applications, which affects whether North Dakota’s application would count toward the threshold.
  • The resolution does not set out rules for the convention or explain how its scope would be kept limited to this subject.