Urges use of biological sex for women's eligibility

Summary#

SCR-4010 is a North Dakota concurrent resolution, not a law changing sports eligibility rules. It was withdrawn from further consideration. Its stated goal is to get the NCAA and other sports-governing bodies to use biological sex to set eligibility for women’s sports.

  • The resolution calls on the NCAA to revoke its transgender student-athlete eligibility policy and bar transgender-identifying males from women’s rosters and competitions.
  • It asks the NCAA to require its member conferences to use a biological-sex-based policy across all sports and divisions.
  • It urges all US sports-governing bodies to protect women’s sports for biological women and girls.
  • If adopted, it directs North Dakota’s Secretary of State to send copies to the named sports organizations and the President of the United States.

What it means for you#

  • Athletes and colleges: The resolution itself does not change eligibility rules or require colleges, conferences, or sports organizations to change their policies. It asks those organizations to act.
  • North Dakota residents: It creates no new state eligibility rule, benefit, fine, or enforcement power. It was withdrawn, so the Legislature did not adopt the requests in this resolution.
  • Secretary of State: The resolution directs the Secretary to send copies to named recipients, but it was withdrawn and that direction did not take effect.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The resolution contains no appropriation or cost estimate. Sending copies is its only stated administrative action.

What is unclear#

  • “Biological sex” and “transgender identifying males” are not defined in the resolution.
  • It does not explain how the requested eligibility rules would be applied, or whether there would be exceptions or a process for decisions and appeals.
  • The supplied material does not include evidence for the resolution’s claims about competitive disadvantage, safety, or effects on female athletes.

Case for#

  • The resolution says women’s sports provide athletic opportunities and can support girls’ health, confidence, and discipline.
  • It argues that biological differences can affect competitive fairness and safety in women’s sports.
  • A possible argument for a shared policy is that it could set the same eligibility approach across NCAA conferences, sports, and divisions.

Case against#

  • The request would bar transgender-identifying males from all women’s rosters and collegiate competitions, without distinguishing among sports or individual circumstances.
  • The resolution does not define key terms or explain how the requested rules would work in practice.
  • Its claims about fairness and safety are not supported with evidence in the supplied material.
  • Because the resolution was withdrawn, it did not change the rules it criticizes.