Court urged to overturn Obergefell

Summary#

HCR 3013, “A concurrent resolution urging the United States Supreme Court to restore the definition of marriage to a union between one man and one woman,” is a resolution, not a bill amending state law. It urges the U.S. Supreme Court to overturn Obergefell v. Hodges and return marriage laws to the states; its stated goal is to restore state and public control over marriage policy. It has passed the North Dakota House, but the supplied status does not show Senate passage.

  • If both chambers adopt it, the Legislature would formally reject Obergefell and urge the Supreme Court to overturn that decision.
  • The resolution says marriage should be defined as a union between one biological male and one biological female.
  • If adopted, it directs North Dakota’s Secretary of State to send a copy to the U.S. Supreme Court.
  • The resolution does not itself change who may marry, require anyone to act on its view of marriage, or overturn the Supreme Court decision.

What it means for you#

  • Same-sex couples: The resolution would not itself change marriage licenses or the legal status of marriages. It asks the Supreme Court to change the law; it does not do so.
  • North Dakota residents: The resolution would express the Legislature’s position, if both chambers adopt it. It does not set new state rules for marriage.
  • Secretary of State: If adopted, the Secretary must send a copy to the Supreme Court.
  • Supreme Court: The resolution sends the Court a request, not a binding instruction.

Money#

No publicly available information on the cost is included in the supplied material.

  • The resolution requires the Secretary of State to send a copy if it is adopted, but gives no cost estimate.

What is unclear#

  • The supplied status says the House passed the resolution but does not say whether the Senate has acted.
  • The resolution does not specify what North Dakota marriage laws should be if the Supreme Court overturns Obergefell.
  • It does not set out steps, timing, or rules for changing state law.
  • It does not explain how different state marriage laws would work alongside one another.

Case for#

  • The resolution’s stated case is that states and their voters, rather than the Supreme Court, should decide marriage policy.
  • A possible argument for the resolution is that it gives the Legislature a way to formally express that view and ask the Court to reconsider its decision.
  • The resolution also argues that the decision harms religious liberty. It does not, however, create a new religious-liberty protection.

Case against#

  • The resolution would ask the Court to overturn a decision that requires states to issue marriage licenses to same-sex couples and recognize their marriages. If the Court did so and returned the issue to the states, marriage rules could differ among states.
  • The resolution itself would not change the law or ensure the Court acts on its request.
  • It does not explain what state rules should replace the current ones, leaving the practical consequences of its request unspecified.

Votes

The recorded vote on this bill, member by member.

  1. Division No. 1498334

    Passed92 members voted

    House Second reading, adopted yeas 52 nays 40

    FOR · 52AGAINST · 40

    52For

    • Republican52

    40Against

    • Republican29
    • Democratic11

    1 member was paired and sat out the vote.