Five-district public service commission would elect commissioners

Summary#

SCR 4015, “The election of public service commissioners,” is a North Dakota Senate concurrent resolution proposing an amendment to section 2 of article V of the state Constitution. It would provide for five public service commissioners elected from five districts; its stated goal is to increase the commission from three members to five. The Senate failed to adopt the resolution, so it did not advance the proposed amendment to voters.

  • The proposal would require the Legislative Assembly to divide the state into five compact, connected districts and elect one commissioner from each for a four-year term.
  • A commissioner would have to be a qualified elector in the district they represent on election day.
  • The Legislature would have to establish initial districts before January 1, 2027, based on the 2020 census, and redraw districts after each decennial census to make voting power as equal as practicable.
  • The proposal says the two additional commissioners would be elected in 2028 and take office January 1, 2029.

What it means for you#

  • Voters: If the proposal had advanced and voters approved it, the text would provide for commissioners elected by district. It directs the amendment to be submitted at the 2026 general election, but this resolution failed in the Senate.
  • Legislature: The proposal would require lawmakers to create the initial districts by the stated deadline and establish districts again after each decennial census.
  • Public Service Commission: The proposed change would increase its membership to five. The supplied material does not describe changes to the commission’s other powers or duties.

Money#

No publicly available information.

  • The proposal assigns district-drawing work to the Legislature, but the supplied material gives no cost estimate or funding source.

What is unclear#

  • The proposal’s election sentence still lists “three public service commissioners,” while a later sentence says the commission consists of five and requires five district elections. The text does not resolve this inconsistency.
  • The current constitutional text was not supplied separately, so the full change from current law cannot be verified against it.
  • The material does not give rules for drawing districts beyond compactness, connection, and equal voting power as nearly as practicable.
  • The title refers to an effective date, but the supplied text has no separate effective-date provision.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the proposal is that five district-elected commissioners could give each district a representative on the commission.
  • Requiring districts to be redrawn after each census, with voting power kept as equal as practicable, could make representation more even across the state.
  • Setting an initial district deadline and a first election date would provide a timetable for moving to the proposed five-member commission.

Case against#

  • The text’s conflicting references to three and five commissioners leave uncertainty about the required number and election arrangement.
  • The proposal gives the Legislature district-drawing duties but does not specify a process or other safeguards for drawing the maps.
  • No cost estimate or funding source is provided for districting or the additional two commissioners.

Votes

The recorded vote on this bill, member by member.

  1. Division No. 1498439

    Defeated47 members voted

    Senate Second reading

    AGAINST · 38FOR · 9

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    38Against

    • Republican37
    • Democratic1

    9For

    • Republican5
    • Democratic4