Study on Separate Party Ballots

Summary#

SCR-4016 is a North Dakota Senate concurrent resolution, not a bill changing election law. It would direct the Legislative Management to consider studying primary procedures for partisan races, including whether separate ballots based on political party would improve the state’s primary elections. It failed to pass, so it did not create a study, change ballots, or change access to voting records.

  • The proposed study would examine primary procedures and the possible use of separate party ballots.
  • The resolution would ask the Legislative Management to report its findings and recommendations, and any legislation needed to carry them out, to the Seventieth Legislative Assembly.
  • The resolution’s recitals say that voting history is not accessible for political purposes and that political parties should have access to it. The resolution does not itself change access to that information.

What it means for you#

  • Voters: No change to how you vote or which ballot you receive resulted from this resolution.
  • Political parties: The resolution did not give parties access to voters’ primary-election records.
  • Legislative Management: Had the resolution passed, it would have had to consider whether to study the issue. The resolution does not specify what the study would cover or how it would be carried out.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The resolution provides no funding or cost estimate for a possible study.

What is unclear#

  • Whether Legislative Management would have chosen to conduct a study, since the resolution says to consider studying.
  • What “enrich” the primary election means, or how the study would assess that.
  • What a separate party ballot would look like, who could receive each ballot, or how party-based voting records would be handled.
  • Whether a report would still be required if Legislative Management decided not to study the issue.

Case for#

  • A study could give lawmakers information about how separate party ballots might affect primary elections before they consider legislation.
  • The resolution identifies a question about political parties’ access to primary voting records, while proposing a study rather than changing access immediately.
  • A report could give the next Legislature findings and recommendations, along with any legislation needed to act on them.

Case against#

  • The resolution did not require the study itself; Legislative Management could consider the question without conducting one.
  • It leaves the study’s scope and methods open, so the resolution does not ensure that specific questions about ballots or access to voting records would be answered.
  • It does not explain what “enrich” means or how any proposed change would be judged.