Study on disability proficiency to address disparities

Summary#

Senate Concurrent Resolution No. 4019 is an enacted North Dakota resolution; it does not amend an existing law or create a new education program. It directs the Legislative Management to consider studying reading and mathematics proficiency among students with disabilities and how well current policies, programs, and resources address disparities. Its stated goal is to identify possible ways to reduce those disparities.

  • The Legislative Management is asked to decide whether to undertake the study; the resolution does not require it to do so.
  • If a study is undertaken, it is to compare students with disabilities’ statewide reading and mathematics assessment results with overall state proficiency rates and examine trends and disparities.
  • The study is to examine possible contributing factors, including special education funding, access to trained teachers and support staff, rural–urban differences, and access to evidence-based curricula and teaching approaches.
  • It is to review state- and federally funded programs, seek input from families, educators, school administrators, special education professionals, and disability-rights advocacy groups, and examine practices used in other states.
  • If the study is done, the resolution calls for findings and recommendations, including any legislation needed to carry them out, to be reported to the Seventieth Legislative Assembly.

What it means for you#

  • Students with disabilities and their families: The resolution does not change students’ services, rights, or eligibility. If a study is undertaken, it is to seek input from parents and families.
  • Schools and education staff: The resolution does not require schools to change teaching, staffing, or funding. Those issues are among the matters a study would examine.
  • Taxpayers and the public: The resolution creates no direct tax, fee, benefit, or new front-line service. Any policy changes would require later action.

Money#

No publicly available information on costs or funding is included in the supplied material.

  • The resolution does not state a study budget, require new staff, or specify how any study would be funded.
  • It asks the study, if undertaken, to consider recommendations about funding, costs, and resource allocation; it does not itself allocate money.

What is unclear#

  • Whether the Legislative Management will choose to conduct the study.
  • If it does, the study’s timing, method, scope, and resources are not specified.
  • The resolution does not set rules for how families or other groups would be asked for input.
  • It does not say how recommendations would be assessed or whether any would be put into effect.

Case for#

  • A study could give lawmakers a clearer picture of proficiency gaps by comparing assessment results for students with disabilities with overall state rates.
  • Examining funding, staffing, geography, and access to teaching resources could help identify barriers that are not addressed by looking at test results alone.
  • Seeking input from families and education professionals, and examining practices elsewhere, could inform recommendations tailored to the state’s needs.

Case against#

  • The Legislative Management is asked only to consider a study, so the resolution does not ensure the questions will be examined.
  • If a study happens, the resolution sets no timeline, research method, or budget, which could affect how detailed or useful its findings are.
  • A study and its recommendations would not themselves change services, funding, or policies; further legislative action may be needed.