New rule caps institutional home buyers

Summary#

HB 1003, the Neighborhood Protection Act, is an introduced bill that would create new rules in Ohio Revised Code Chapter 1749 and amend the state income-tax law in Chapter 5747. Its stated goal is to affect institutional investors’ purchases of certain homes and their use of federal tax deductions; the bill does not guarantee a particular housing outcome.

  • A “covered entity”—including a qualifying institutional real estate investor or an entity it funds to buy a home—could not buy, acquire, or offer to buy a one- or two-family home unless it had been listed for sale to the public for at least 30 days.
  • The bill exempts certain nonprofits, county land reutilization corporations, and creditors or loan servicers taking property to satisfy a secured debt. A generally available mortgage loan would not count as investor funding.
  • The Ohio Department of Commerce director may hold a hearing over a suspected violation. If the director finds a violation, the director must impose a civil penalty of up to $250,000 per violation; the attorney general must sue to collect it if the director makes a written request.
  • For Ohio income-tax purposes, the bill would require adding back certain federal interest and depreciation deductions tied to covered property owned by an institutional real estate investor. The interest add-back has a stated exception for certain sales; the depreciation add-back does not state one.

What it means for you#

  • Home sellers: If a covered entity wants to buy your one- or two-family home, it could not make an offer or acquire an interest until the home had been publicly listed for at least 30 days.
  • Institutional investors and entities they fund: The restriction applies to purchases, acquisitions, and offers—not only completed sales. An institutional investor is defined by home ownership, pooled investor funds and fiduciary activity, and a $25 million asset or net-value threshold. A public, generally available mortgage loan is excluded from the funding test.
  • Taxpayers connected to investor-owned property: The new add-backs could increase Ohio taxable income for an investor or a taxpayer with a share of a pass-through entity’s deductions.
  • Other Ohio residents: The bill does not directly create a housing benefit, ban institutional ownership, require investors to sell homes, or set a home price or rent.

Money#

The bill gives no estimate of public costs, tax revenue, or private costs.

  • The Department of Commerce may hold enforcement hearings, and the attorney general must bring a collection action upon the director’s written request. The bill gives no staffing or cost estimate.
  • The tax add-backs could increase Ohio income-tax liability for affected taxpayers. The amount of any added revenue is not stated.
  • Violations may bring a civil penalty of up to $250,000 each.

What is unclear#

  • The supplied text does not define “covered property,” a key term in the tax provisions.
  • It does not give a start date or explain how the 30-day listing period would be verified.
  • The bill does not specify how violations would be counted, or provide details such as hearing timelines, appeals, or enforcement reporting.
  • The parent version of Ohio’s income-tax law was not supplied, so the available materials do not let me verify whether any of these rules overlap with current law.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to give individual buyers and other public buyers time to compete before covered entities can make offers on homes.
  • A possible argument for the 30-day rule is that it creates a clear waiting period without banning covered entities from buying homes.
  • The tax add-backs could limit the value of specified federal deductions for investor-owned property under Ohio’s income-tax rules.

Case against#

  • A 30-day listing rule does not guarantee that an individual buyer will purchase the home or that the price will be lower.
  • The bill’s definition of “covered property” is missing from the supplied text, making the tax change’s reach unclear.
  • The bill authorizes large penalties but leaves key enforcement details unstated.
  • The bill does not estimate the tax effects or the cost of enforcement.