Agencies Could No Longer Call Funded Programs “Free”

Summary#

HB 1044, titled “Prohibit state agencies describing GRF-funded programs as ‘free,’” would create a new section of Ohio law; it does not amend an existing Act. Its stated goal is to stop state agencies from describing programs funded in whole or in part by the state’s general revenue fund as “free.”

  • State agencies, and their officials and employees acting in their official roles, could not use the word “free” in public communications to describe or explain a covered program, grant, service, or other public benefit.
  • “Public communication” includes websites, flyers, and other literature, as well as other communications to the public.
  • Agencies would have to update or remove existing communications that violate the ban within six months after the law takes effect.
  • The ban would not cover political subdivisions or their agencies, or state institutions of higher education.
  • The bill would change how agencies describe programs, not whether those programs are offered or who qualifies. It is introduced and is not law; passage is uncertain.

What it means for you#

  • People using state programs: The bill would not itself change a program’s eligibility, availability, services, or fees. It would restrict the word agencies can use when describing or explaining covered programs.
  • State agencies and employees: They would have to follow the word-use ban in public communications and update or remove existing material within six months of the law taking effect.
  • Local governments and state institutions of higher education: They are excluded from the bill’s definition of “state agency.”
  • Taxpayers: The bill would not change taxes or require agencies to say what a program costs or how it is funded.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The bill would require agencies to update or remove existing communications, but it gives no estimate of the staff time or cost.
  • It does not appropriate money or set fees, fines, or other charges.

What is unclear#

  • The bill text does not state when the law would take effect; the six-month update period would run from that date.
  • It does not set a penalty or enforcement process for violations.
  • It does not explain how an agency should handle a communication that uses “free” in a different sense, or what review process it should use.
  • It does not say whether agencies must replace the word with information about funding or program costs.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that “free” could make a publicly funded program sound costless, even though the program uses state funds.
  • A consistent restriction could make agencies more careful about how they describe benefits paid for in whole or in part from the general revenue fund.
  • The bill applies to a defined group of state agencies and communications, rather than changing the programs themselves.

Case against#

  • The ban applies to any public communication describing or explaining a covered program, including programs funded only partly by the general revenue fund. That could restrict ordinary wording even when a service has no charge to the person using it.
  • The bill does not require agencies to explain the program’s funding or cost as an alternative, so it may limit wording without ensuring more information for the public.
  • The bill gives no penalty, enforcement process, or guidance for difficult cases, leaving those details unclear.