Bill limits rescinding health orders

Summary#

HB 1038, titled “Revise GA authority to rescind Director of Health actions, orders,” would amend Ohio Revised Code section 101.36, replacing its existing text. Its stated goal, as reflected in the title, is to revise the General Assembly’s authority over actions and orders of the Director of Health. The bill is introduced and is not law.

  • The General Assembly could rescind, in whole or in part, certain Health Department disease-control orders or rules and certain actions by the Director of Health, by concurrent resolution.
  • After a rescission, the department could not for 60 days reissue the rescinded measure, take the same or a substantially similar action, or issue a restriction contained in it.
  • Within those 60 days, the governor could ask the General Assembly to allow the department or director to issue the rescinded measure again. The General Assembly could authorize this, in whole or in part, by concurrent resolution.
  • A measure issued or action taken in violation of these rules would be invalid and have no legal effect.

What it means for you#

  • Ohio residents: The bill would not itself rescind any particular health order or action. If the General Assembly rescinded one, the bill’s 60-day limit could prevent the department from restoring it or issuing a substantially similar measure during that period.
  • General Assembly: It could rescind the specified orders, rules, or actions by concurrent resolution, and could later authorize their return after a governor’s request.
  • Health Department and Director of Health: They would have to follow the 60-day limits. The bill does not set a process for deciding whether a later measure is “substantially similar.”
  • Governor: The governor could request permission for a rescinded measure to be issued again, but could not authorize it alone.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The bill provides no spending amount or staffing estimate.
  • It gives the Health Department, director, governor, and General Assembly roles under the proposed rules, but does not specify the cost of carrying them out.

What is unclear#

  • The existing text of section 101.36 is not supplied, so the available material does not show how much of the proposal changes current law.
  • The bill does not define “substantially similar” or “restriction.”
  • It does not set criteria or a deadline for the General Assembly to decide a governor’s request.
  • It does not explain how the proposed rules would interact with other laws or health powers.
  • The bill text does not set a start date. Passage is uncertain because the bill is only introduced.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that it gives the elected General Assembly a way to stop specified health measures it considers inappropriate.
  • The 60-day bar could prevent the department from immediately restoring a rescinded measure under a different name or in a similar form.
  • The governor could ask the legislature to allow a measure to return, giving the General Assembly a role in that decision.

Case against#

  • One concern is that a 60-day bar could limit the department’s ability to respond if disease conditions change after a measure is rescinded.
  • The bill does not set criteria the General Assembly must use when rescinding a measure or considering the governor’s request.
  • Because “substantially similar” is undefined, it may be unclear which replacement actions or restrictions the department could issue during the 60-day period.