Summary#
Bill 101, the Enhancing Shareholder Rights Act, 2017, would amend Ontario’s Business Corporations Act. Its stated goal is to change shareholder meetings and director elections, require diversity information from certain corporations, and let shareholders propose executive compensation policies. The supplied material does not include the current Act, so I could not verify how these rules compare with current law.
- Shareholders meeting a 3% ownership threshold could propose one director nominee or requisition a shareholder meeting.
- Director elections would use separate votes for each candidate and, in the circumstances set out in the bill, require a majority of votes cast. Shareholders present in person would have to vote for or against every candidate.
- Certain corporations would have to provide prescribed information about diversity among directors and senior management at each annual meeting, send it to shareholders unless they opt out, and send it to the Director.
- Eligible shareholders could propose adopting, changing or repealing an executive compensation policy. If shareholders adopt a policy, directors would have to set directors’ and officers’ pay in line with it.
- The bill would take effect on Royal Assent. The supplied material does not state the bill’s current status.
What it means for you#
- Shareholders: One or more registered holders or beneficial owners could propose a single director nominee if they together hold at least 3% of the corporation’s shares, or 3% of a voting class or series. One or more holders or beneficial owners with at least 3% of issued shares could requisition a meeting.
- Shareholders: Proxy forms would have to let you choose for or against each director candidate and name nominees proposed through the bill’s process. If you are entitled to vote and attend an election in person, you would have to vote for or against every candidate.
- Shareholders: A person claiming beneficial ownership would need to provide proof to vote in a director election. Eligible registered holders and beneficial owners could propose an executive compensation policy at an annual meeting, but the bill does not require shareholders to adopt one.
- Corporations and directors: Prescribed corporations would have to prepare and send diversity information each year. Directors would have to follow any adopted executive compensation policy when setting directors’ and officers’ pay.
- Corporations: The bill would not itself cap pay, require a particular diversity level, or require every corporation to report diversity information. Which corporations and what information are prescribed is not stated in the bill text supplied.
Money#
No publicly available information on the bill’s costs is included in the supplied material.
- Corporations covered by the diversity rule would have to prepare and send information; proxy and meeting rules would also create administrative work. The cost is not estimated.
- The bill includes no stated appropriation, fee, fine, tax change or public funding amount.
What is unclear#
- Which corporations would be covered by the diversity disclosure rule, and what information they would have to provide, depend on regulations not included here.
- The bill does not set out how shareholders would propose, debate or vote on an executive compensation policy beyond referring to the existing proposal process.
- The bill refers to prescribed circumstances in which an unsuccessful director candidate may be appointed before the next election; those circumstances are not supplied.
- The current rules in the Business Corporations Act, and how these amendments would interact with them, could not be checked because the Act was not supplied.
Case for#
- The bill appears intended to give shareholders more ways to put director candidates and meeting issues before a corporation.
- Separate votes and a majority-vote requirement could make each director’s election result clearer to shareholders.
- Annual diversity disclosures could give shareholders information about directors and senior management.
- A shareholder-approved compensation policy would give shareholders a way to set guidance that directors must follow when fixing pay.
Case against#
- The bill leaves important details to regulations, including which corporations report and what diversity information they disclose.
- The 3% thresholds may limit who can use the proposal and meeting-requisition powers; the bill provides no estimate of how many shareholders could meet them.
- Corporations would have new reporting and election-related duties, but the bill gives no cost estimate.
- The bill sets out an effect for adopted compensation policies but does not explain how the policy process would work in practice.