Summary#
Bill 102, the French Language Services in MPP Constituency Offices Act, 2017, would amend Ontario’s French Language Services Act. Its stated goal is to extend that Act’s French-language service rules to MPP constituency offices.
- It adds constituency offices to the Act’s definition of a provider of services to the public. “Service” includes procedures and communications for that purpose.
- A person would have the right to communicate in French with, and receive available services in French from, a constituency office located in or serving an area designated in the Act’s Schedule.
- The duties would be subject to limits that are reasonable and necessary in the circumstances, if all reasonable measures and plans for compliance have been taken or made.
- The text says the changes would come into force on June 8, 2018. The supplied material does not say whether the bill passed or took effect.
What it means for you#
- People using MPP constituency offices: If the office is located in or serves a designated area, you would have the stated right to communicate in French and receive services that are available in French. The bill does not say that every service must be offered in French.
- MPP constituency offices: They would be covered by the Act’s obligations, subject to the stated limits. The bill does not set out an application or complaint process.
- People outside designated areas: The bill does not extend this right to constituency offices outside the stated coverage, unless they serve a designated area.
- Current law: The bill amends the French Language Services Act. The parent Act was not supplied, so I could not verify the full current rules, the Schedule’s coverage, or how these duties would interact with existing provisions.
Money#
No cost information is in the available material.
- The text provides no funding amount, staffing requirement, fee, or fine.
- Offices would have new duties under the Act, but the bill gives no estimate of the cost of meeting them.
What is unclear#
- The Schedule listing designated areas was not supplied, so the exact coverage cannot be confirmed.
- The bill does not explain how it would be decided whether an office “serves” a designated area.
- The supplied text does not define “available services” or explain how that phrase applies to different services and communications.
- It does not explain how offices would show they had taken all reasonable measures and made plans, or who would decide whether a limit is reasonable and necessary.
- The supplied material does not describe enforcement, complaints, funding, or whether the bill passed and its stated start date took effect.
Case for#
- The bill appears intended to make French-language service rights apply to MPP offices as well as the other public-facing offices named in the Act.
- Including communications and procedures in the definition of “service” could make clear that the right covers more than a final service or transaction.
- The limits in the bill allow for reasonable and necessary exceptions, while still requiring reasonable measures and plans for compliance.
Case against#
- The bill does not spell out what services must be available in French or how an office’s coverage area would be determined.
- The exception for limits that are “reasonable and necessary” is not explained in the supplied text, leaving uncertainty about how it would be applied.
- The bill creates duties but gives no funding or staffing details, so the resources needed to meet them are unknown.