Summary#
Bill 111, the Supply Act, 2017, is an enacted Ontario law that authorized spending and investments for the 2016–17 fiscal year. Its stated purpose was to provide amounts for the public-service and Legislative Office purposes listed in its schedules; it was repealed on April 1, 2018.
- It authorized up to $127.08 billion for public-service expenses and up to $4.25 billion for public-service investments, including capital assets, loans and other investments.
- It authorized up to $225.38 million for the expenses of the Legislative Offices.
- The amounts had to be used according to the votes and items in the estimates. They could be paid from the Consolidated Revenue Fund or, where allowed, recorded as non-cash expenses or investments.
- A ministry assigned responsibility for a program or activity during the fiscal year could incur or record the related expenditure through that ministry.
- It repealed two interim appropriation laws for 2016–17.
What it means for you#
- Government ministries: The law gave authority to pay or record eligible expenses and investments for 2016–17, up to the listed limits. It did not require the full amounts to be spent.
- Legislative Offices: The Assembly, Auditor General, Chief Electoral Officer and Ombudsman Ontario had authorized funding for expenses, within the listed total.
- Taxpayers and the public: This was a government funding law for a past fiscal year. It does not create a new ongoing program or directly change taxes, fees, benefits or eligibility rules.
Money#
The law authorized up to $131.56 billion in total for 2016–17; this is a spending and investment limit, not evidence that the full amount was spent.
- Up to $127.08 billion could be paid or recorded as non-cash expenses for public-service costs.
- Up to $4.25 billion could be paid or recorded as non-cash investments.
- Up to $225.38 million could be paid for Legislative Office expenses.
- No publicly available information on actual spending is included in the supplied material.
What is unclear#
- The supplied material does not show how much of the authorized money was actually spent or invested.
- The schedules show amounts by ministry and estimates, but the supplied material does not explain the underlying programs or results.
- The law authorizes funding for the listed purposes but does not set out how the funded activities were delivered.
Case for#
- The law set maximum amounts and tied their use to votes and items in the estimates, providing legal authority for public spending within stated limits.
- It covered expenses, investments and Legislative Office costs in one supply law for the fiscal year.
- Allowing a ministry assigned responsibility for a program to incur its expenses could let the government account for spending through the ministry responsible for that work.
Case against#
- The authorized totals are very large, while the supplied material does not show actual spending or what results the money produced.
- The law’s schedules list amounts by ministry and estimate category, but do not explain the funded activities in enough detail to assess them from this material alone.
- The law allowed amounts to be spent or recorded as non-cash expenses or investments, which may make it harder for a reader to tell from the authorization alone how much cash was paid out.