New Ministry for Mental Health and Addictions

Summary#

Bill 149, the Ministry of Mental Health and Addictions Act, 2017, would create a new law establishing an Ontario Ministry of Mental Health and Addictions; it does not amend another Act. Its stated goal is to improve access to coordinated mental health and addictions care across Ontario.

  • The Minister would lead and be responsible for the Ministry and its functions, including developing, managing and coordinating the mental health and addictions system.
  • The Minister would be responsible for all funding decisions for mental health and addictions programs and services.
  • The Minister’s listed duties include developing a core basket of services, leading a wait-times strategy, and updating and implementing outstanding recommendations from a 2010 select committee.
  • The Minister would have to work with communities, organizations, stakeholders and governments on public health emergencies, including opioid addiction and overdose fatalities, with an urgent objective to save lives.
  • The Minister or Lieutenant Governor in Council could appoint advisory committees. The Minister would have to submit an annual report on the Ministry’s affairs to the Lieutenant Governor in Council and then present it to the Legislature.

What it means for you#

  • People seeking mental health or addictions care: The bill assigns the Minister responsibility for timely and equitable access, coordinated services, and navigation of supports such as housing, income, employment and peer support. These are stated duties and goals; the bill does not create an individual right to a service or set eligibility rules, service standards or wait-time limits.
  • Community organizations and service providers: The Minister would have to consult stakeholders and work with community partners. The bill does not require providers to change how they operate or create a process for people to apply for services.
  • Ontario government: A new ministry would be established. The Minister could delegate powers or duties in writing to specified Ministry staff, public servants, or staff and board members of agencies or entities assigned to the Minister.
  • The public: The Minister would have to report each year on the Ministry’s affairs. The bill does not specify what information the report must contain.

Money#

No publicly available information on the bill’s cost is included in the supplied material.

  • The bill gives the Minister responsibility for all funding decisions about mental health and addictions programs and services, but does not set out funding amounts or appropriate money.
  • It establishes a ministry but does not specify staffing levels, operating resources or costs.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not say how existing programs, staff, budgets or responsibilities would move to the new Ministry, or how its work would overlap with other ministries. The supplied material does not establish what arrangements are in place now.
  • It does not define key terms such as “core basket” of services or specify how the Minister’s broad duties would be measured or enforced.
  • It does not set out how the wait-times strategy would work, what services it would cover, or how the stated goal of eliminating wait lists would be assessed.
  • It does not say how the Minister would identify the 2010 recommendations still outstanding, or what the annual report must include.
  • The bill says committees may be appointed, but does not require any committee or specify who would be represented.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to put responsibility for mental health and addictions services in one ministry, which could make coordination and accountability clearer.
  • A province-wide service plan and wait-times strategy could help address gaps in access, while allowing regional and cultural differences.
  • The Minister’s listed duties include prevention, early intervention, treatment and community supports, as well as links to housing, income and employment services.
  • The bill calls for urgent cooperation on public health emergencies, including opioid addiction and overdose fatalities.

Case against#

  • The bill assigns broad responsibilities but does not provide funding, staffing, service standards, timelines or a way to enforce the stated access goals.
  • The Minister would control all funding decisions for these programs and services, but the bill does not describe decision criteria or oversight of those decisions.
  • The Ministry’s duties may overlap with existing responsibilities; the bill does not explain how those would be coordinated or transferred.
  • Advisory committees are optional, and the bill does not require particular community or service-user representation.

Votes

The recorded vote on this bill, member by member.

  1. Division No. 2017091401

    Passed42 members voted

    Second Reading of Bill 149

    FOR · 24AGAINST · 18

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    24For

    • NDP15
    • PC9

    18Against

    • Liberal18