Life leases bill overhauls fees

Summary#

Bill 155, Life Leases Act, 2017, would create a new Ontario law; it does not amend an existing Act. It would set rules for life leases—written rental agreements with an entrance fee and a right to occupy for life or for at least 50 years. The bill’s stated aim is to regulate payments and require information and protections for tenants.

  • Landlords would have to give prospective tenants information about entrance fees, other fees, management, finances, refunds and expected completion dates before taking a pre-lease payment.
  • Landlords would have to follow rules for holding pre-lease payments and entrance fees in trust, and for refunds and cancellation rights. A tenant generally could cancel within seven days after signing, before taking possession.
  • Landlords would have to hold at least four tenant meetings a year and maintain insurance. A “prescribed landlord” (one covered by regulations) would also have to maintain a reserve fund for unforeseen major repairs or replacement of complex assets.
  • For initial tenants, landlords would have to appoint a trustee to receive and administer entrance fees. If entrance fees are refundable, the landlord would have to set up a refund fund and contribute the amount set by regulations.
  • False or misleading material statements, and other violations of the Act or regulations, could be offences. The maximum fines and jail terms would depend on the offence, whether the person is an individual or corporation, and whether it is a first or later offence.

What it means for you#

  • Prospective tenants and tenants: Before a landlord takes a pre-lease payment, it would have to disclose specified information, including estimated fees and refunds. Pre-lease payments would have to be held in trust. The bill would give tenants cancellation and refund rights in certain situations, including when possession is more than 30 days late.
  • Tenants: You could not waive the Act’s protections by agreement. Landlords would have to give tenants meeting notices; tenants selected as representatives under regulations could attend and speak at board meetings, subject to limits for personal information.
  • Landlords and life-lease developers: They would have to meet the bill’s disclosure, payment, insurance, meeting and trustee requirements. The bill also sets rules for entrance-fee refunds and for access to audited financial statements in some cases.
  • Taxpayers: The bill does not create a tax, public benefit, or new agency. It does not identify who would enforce the offences.

Money#

No public cost estimate is available in the supplied material.

  • The bill does not appropriate money or set a public spending amount.
  • Landlords would have to pay for required insurance and, where prescribed, maintain a reserve fund. They would also have costs related to trustees, disclosures and meetings; the bill gives no estimates.
  • Tenants would pay entrance fees and other fees set under their leases. The bill would require refunds in specified circumstances, but leaves some refund rules and amounts to regulations.

What is unclear#

  • The bill leaves many important details to regulations, including which landlords must keep reserve funds, trustee qualifications, payment limits, minimum refundable amounts and the amount landlords must contribute to refund funds.
  • The bill would start on a date set by proclamation. No start date is given in the supplied text.
  • The bill says it applies to life leases made before or after it comes into force, but the supplied material does not explain how its requirements would apply to existing leases in practice.
  • The bill does not set out a process for tenants to make claims, challenge decisions or appeal. It also does not name an enforcement body.
  • The supplied material does not include current Ontario tenancy law or regulations, so it is not possible to verify how these proposed rules would compare with existing protections or interact with other laws.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to address the financial and timing risks of paying a large entrance fee for a long-term rental arrangement.
  • Requiring disclosure before a pre-lease payment could help tenants compare costs, management arrangements and likely refunds before committing money.
  • Trust rules, refund funds and cancellation rights could offer protection if a development is delayed, a lease is cancelled or an entrance fee is owed back.
  • Regular meetings and access to some financial information could give tenants more insight into how their residential complex is run.

Case against#

  • Many key protections depend on regulations that are not included here, so tenants and landlords cannot tell from the bill alone what several requirements would be.
  • The bill would require landlords to fund insurance, reserve funds and refund funds, but provides no cost estimates or rules for how those costs relate to tenant fees.
  • The bill gives tenants some meeting and information rights, but does not establish a general tenant decision-making role or a process for resolving disputes.
  • It is unclear how the rules would work for existing life leases, and how they would fit with other laws or programs.