Summary#
Bill 87, the Protecting Patients Act, 2017, was enacted as Chapter 11 of Ontario’s 2017 statutes. It amends several health laws and repeals and replaces the Elderly Persons Centres Act with the Seniors Active Living Centres Act, 2017. Its stated goal is to implement measures relating to health and seniors.
- Health profession regulators gain earlier power to suspend a member or restrict their practice while a complaint is being handled, if the member may put patients at risk. The bill also sets mandatory suspension or revocation rules for certain sexual-abuse findings.
- People who allege sexual abuse by a regulated health professional become eligible to seek College-funded therapy or counselling. Members must report certain charges and findings by other professional bodies to their College.
- Parents must complete an immunization education session before filing a religious-belief or conscience statement to exempt a child from school immunization requirements.
- Laboratory licensing changes include emergency licence suspensions, new inspection powers, and a Minister’s power to block or limit licences on public-interest grounds.
- The Minister may arrange payment to health facilities on a basis other than fee-for-service, and may designate hospitals to provide community laboratory services.
- Approved seniors’ programs may receive provincial grants. For a program in a municipality, a municipal contribution is required; the usual amount in the Act is 20% of net annual costs, but regulations may change that amount.
What it means for you#
- Patients: A College may impose an interim suspension or practice limits earlier in a complaint process when it believes a member’s conduct puts patients at risk. For sexual abuse, certain conduct requires revocation; other sexual-abuse findings require suspension unless the certificate is otherwise revoked. These are regulatory measures, not a finding that every allegation is proven.
- People alleging sexual abuse: A College must have a funding program for therapy or counselling. Eligibility can be based on an allegation in a complaint or report; receiving funding is not itself a finding against the professional. Funding is reduced by amounts OHIP or private insurance must pay.
- Health professionals: Members must report being charged with an offence, including bail conditions or other restrictions, and must report professional misconduct or incompetence findings by other professional bodies. The bill does not say those reports are automatically public.
- Parents and immunization providers: Parents seeking a conscience or religious-belief exemption must complete an education session. Physicians, nurses and prescribed providers who administer immunizations must give information to the local medical officer of health.
- Pharmacies: A pharmacy technician may dispense, compound or sell drugs at a remote location without a pharmacist physically present only if a pharmacist actively supervises, the location is accredited for that purpose, and regulations are followed.
- Laboratories and seniors’ programs: Laboratory owners and operators face new licensing, inspection and possible emergency-suspension rules. Seniors’ program operators must get approval for both the operator and program before receiving a grant.
Money#
No overall cost estimate is available in the supplied material.
- Seniors’ grants are paid only from money appropriated for that purpose, and the Minister decides the grant amount. Local contributions are also required in the circumstances set out above.
- Colleges must provide the sexual-abuse therapy and counselling funding program, but no cost estimate or funding limit is given.
- The law allows prescribed licence and laboratory-service fees, and fees for quality-management assessments; the amounts are not supplied.
- The bill requires some agencies and public bodies to act, but the material gives no staffing or implementation cost estimates.
What is unclear#
- Several provisions take effect only on a date set by proclamation. The supplied material does not give those dates, so it does not establish which delayed provisions are currently in force.
- Regulations can set important details, including immunization-session requirements, some licensing rules, the seniors’ grant contribution rate, and other eligibility criteria.
- The bill does not set the amounts or limits for College therapy funding, or fully detail how a person requests it.
- The Minister’s “public interest” test for laboratory licences is broad; the bill lists factors the Minister may consider but does not set a fixed decision rule.
- The supplied material does not include the full earlier versions of the amended Acts, so the full baseline and interaction with existing rules could not be verified.
Case for#
- The bill appears intended to let regulators act sooner when a health professional or pharmacy may pose a risk to patients.
- Requiring reports about charges and findings from other professional bodies may give Colleges information relevant to public protection.
- Education before a non-medical immunization exemption may help parents make an informed decision.
- A provincial grant program, with local contributions, could support seniors’ activities, social engagement and learning.
Case against#
- Interim suspensions can have serious effects before a matter is finally decided. The bill sets notice and submission rules, with an urgent exception, but the process may still affect a member’s ability to practise while a case proceeds.
- The bill gives the Minister broad discretion over laboratory licences and leaves many operating details to regulations.
- Required local contributions could make access to provincial seniors’ grants depend on whether a municipality or other prescribed entity contributes.
- The bill creates new duties and funding arrangements without supplied estimates, so their public and institutional costs are unclear.