Summary#
Bill 15, the Connecting Care Amendment Act (Patient Bill of Rights), 2021, would amend Ontario’s Connecting Care Act, 2019. Its stated goal is to make health service providers respect and promote a set of rights for people receiving care. The supplied material does not include the parent Act, so I could not verify how these proposed rights compare with current law.
- Health service providers would have to ensure the listed rights are “fully respected and promoted.” The rights cover respectful and non-abusive treatment; dignity, privacy and autonomy; care that responds to a person’s needs and preferences; information about services, providers and policies; and participation in certain assessments and care plans.
- The rights would include giving or refusing consent, having a substitute decision-maker when a person cannot make their own health care decisions, and raising concerns without interference, coercion, discrimination or reprisal.
- People would have rights concerning confidential records, knowing who received their personal health information, and getting a complete, accessible health record without delay or unreasonable cost. They would also have rights to information about complaint and appeal options and to continue receiving services without reprisal for a complaint or appeal.
- A person could designate an essential caregiver who provides support or care continuously or occasionally. The person receiving care would have a right to access that caregiver in any health care setting at any time, and to have the caregiver treated with respect as part of the care team.
- A person could apply to the Superior Court of Justice for a declaration that a provider breached the rights or that a law requires or permits a breach. If the court makes a declaration, it could make any order it considers appropriate to enforce the rights.
- The rights would prevail over conflicting provisions in other Acts or regulations unless those provisions specifically say they apply despite these rights. The section would bind the Crown and its agencies.
What it means for you#
- People receiving health services: Providers would have to respect and promote the listed rights. This is not a general promise of a particular treatment or faster access to health care; the bill does not set service levels.
- People applying for services: You would have a right to take part in the provider’s assessment of your needs. If found eligible, you would have rights to take part in developing and reviewing your service plan and in evaluating or revising it.
- People choosing an essential caregiver: You could designate someone who provides the kinds of support or care described in the bill. The bill does not limit this to a family member.
- Health service providers: They would have new express duties under the proposed rights. The bill does not set out a new complaint process, application process, review timeline or appeal system.
- Government and public: The proposed rights would bind the Crown and could take priority over other laws, subject to the bill’s exception for laws that specifically say they apply despite the rights.
Money#
Estimated cost: No publicly available information.
- The bill would require health service providers to meet the new duties, but it gives no estimate of staffing, record-access, compliance or other costs.
- Court applications and orders are authorized, but the bill gives no estimate of related public or private costs.
- The bill does not set a tax, fee, fine or benefit, or make a specific spending appropriation.
What is unclear#
- The supplied material does not include the Connecting Care Act, 2019, so the current definitions of “health service provider” and “health service,” and the existing rights and duties, could not be checked.
- The bill does not explain how the right to a caregiver’s access “at any time” would work alongside other laws or practical limits in a care setting.
- It does not define terms such as “unreasonable cost,” “financial abuse” or “fully respected and promoted.”
- It does not specify how people would make complaints, how providers must respond, or whether a person must use another process before going to court.
- The bill says it would start on Royal Assent; the supplied material does not state whether it passed or received Royal Assent.
Case for#
- A clear list of rights could make expectations for providers and people receiving care easier to identify.
- The rights address not only treatment, but also privacy, consent, personal preferences, information and participation in care decisions.
- A right to an essential caregiver could recognize the support that a designated person provides, including in care settings.
- Court declarations and orders could give a person a way to seek enforcement when a provider breaches the rights.
Case against#
- The bill gives courts broad power to make any order they consider appropriate, but does not set out a specific remedy process or limits on those orders.
- Making these rights prevail over other laws could create conflicts, while the bill does not explain how such conflicts would be resolved except where another law expressly overrides the rights.
- Some key terms are undefined, which could leave people and providers uncertain about what the duties require in practice.
- The bill sets out broad rights but does not create complaint timelines, response requirements or a dedicated oversight process.