Bill targets driving with unlawful handguns

Summary#

Bill 22, the Prohibiting Driving with Unlawful Handguns Act, 2018, would amend Ontario’s Highway Traffic Act and Civil Remedies Act, 2001. It would create an offence of driving on a highway in a motor vehicle containing an unlawfully possessed handgun. Its stated goal is to promote public safety and suppress conditions that lead to crime; the bill does not guarantee that result.

  • A person convicted of the new offence could face a fine of $2,000 to $10,000, up to six months in jail, or both. A court may also suspend their licence: one year for a first conviction, five years for a second, and indefinitely for a third.
  • If a police officer has reasonable and probable grounds to believe the offence occurred, the officer must request the driver’s licence and detain the vehicle. The licence is suspended and the vehicle impounded for seven days.
  • The vehicle’s owner must bear the removal and impound costs and risk. The vehicle cannot be released until those costs are paid. The seven-day impoundment runs at the same time as any impoundment under certain listed Highway Traffic Act provisions.
  • The bill adds a route for a court, in a proceeding started by the Attorney General, to order a vehicle forfeited to Ontario. The order is generally required if the court finds the bill’s conditions are met, subject to limits in the Civil Remedies Act and an exception where forfeiture would clearly not be in the interests of justice.
  • The bill would also make obstructing or interfering with a police officer carrying out these duties an offence, punishable by a fine of $200 to $5,000, up to six months in jail, or both.

What it means for you#

  • Drivers: The offence applies when you drive on a highway a motor vehicle in which there is a handgun whose possession is not authorized under the federal Firearms Act. The bill does not say whether the driver must know the handgun is there; that legal question is unclear from the supplied text.
  • Drivers and vehicle owners: The immediate seven-day licence suspension and impoundment apply when the police officer has the required grounds. There is no appeal or right to be heard before those immediate measures, though court proceedings are not affected. The bill allows early release if an officer is satisfied the vehicle was stolen when the offence occurred.
  • Vehicle owners: You may have to pay removal and storage costs even if someone else was driving. The bill also allows an owner to sue the driver to recover costs or other losses from the impoundment. A vehicle may face forfeiture under the conditions described above.
  • Police and courts: Police must take the specified immediate steps when the grounds exist. Courts decide convictions, penalties and any forfeiture proceeding. A licence counts whether issued in Ontario or another jurisdiction.
  • General public: The bill does not make possession of an unlawfully possessed handgun a new offence by itself, and it does not create a new public service or application process. It targets driving on a highway with such a handgun in the vehicle.

Money#

The bill gives no estimate of public costs or savings; it does require vehicle owners to pay removal and impound costs.

  • A conviction fine is $2,000 to $10,000; obstructing an officer carries a $200 to $5,000 fine. The bill does not say how fine revenue would be used.
  • Impound operators may claim storage costs as a lien on the vehicle, and need not release it until removal and impound costs are paid.
  • No estimate is provided for police, court, administration or enforcement costs.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not state whether a driver must know the handgun is in the vehicle.
  • It does not set out how police grounds would be challenged, beyond saying court proceedings are unaffected; there is no appeal or hearing before the immediate suspension or impoundment.
  • The Highway Traffic Act and Civil Remedies Act as they currently stand were not supplied, so the existing rules and limits on vehicle forfeiture, including the provisions the bill refers to, could not be checked.
  • The bill does not set a start date; it would come into force on a date set by proclamation.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to address the public-safety risk of driving with a handgun that is not legally possessed.
  • Immediate licence suspension and vehicle impoundment could remove the driver and vehicle from the road while the matter proceeds.
  • Possible fines, jail and vehicle forfeiture add consequences beyond the short administrative suspension and impoundment.

Case against#

  • The immediate measures can affect a driver and vehicle owner before a court decides whether an offence occurred, with no pre-action hearing or appeal under this section.
  • Owners may pay impound costs even when someone else drove, and a vehicle may be subject to forfeiture proceedings under the bill’s conditions.
  • The bill does not explain whether knowledge of the handgun matters, leaving an important issue about who may be caught by the offence unclear.
  • The bill provides no estimate of the public cost of enforcement or how the new rules would interact with all existing forfeiture protections.