Plan to curb illegal handgun smuggling unveiled

Summary#

Bill 210 would create a new Ontario law, the Stopping Illegal Handgun Smuggling Act, 2024; it does not amend an existing Act. Its stated goal is to stop illegal handguns from entering Ontario.

  • The Attorney General, or another minister assigned responsibility, must research illegal handgun entry and sales in Ontario, possible ways to address them, and grounds for legal action against manufacturers of handguns made in the United States.
  • Within one year after the Act starts, the Minister must publish a plan. The Minister must consult affected communities, legal professionals involved in litigation against tobacco or pharmaceutical product makers, and law enforcement and border security professionals.
  • If the Minister finds legal action reasonably likely to lead to greater protection for Ontarians, the Minister must take steps to start that action within six months after the plan is developed. The Minister may also develop legislation about the legal action if the Minister considers that in the public interest.
  • Within six months after the plan is developed, the Minister must report on it to the Legislative Assembly, including the reasons for the decision on whether legal action is likely to have the stated effect.

What it means for you#

  • People in affected communities: The Minister must consult with communities affected by illegal handguns while preparing the plan. The bill does not set out how that consultation must happen.
  • Law enforcement, border security and specified legal professionals: The Minister must consult them. The bill does not give them a decision-making role.
  • Gun owners and the general public: The bill does not directly change firearm rules, create a new offence, or give police or border officials new enforcement powers. It requires planning and research, and could lead to legal action against manufacturers.
  • Taxpayers: The bill requires government work on research, consultation, a plan and a report. It does not say how that work would be staffed or funded.

Money#

No publicly available information on expected costs or funding is included in the supplied material.

  • The bill does not set out an appropriation, tax, fee or fine.
  • Research, consultation, publication and reporting would require government work. The bill gives no cost estimate.
  • If the Minister meets the test for legal action, the bill requires steps to start it. It gives no estimate of litigation costs.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not explain how the Minister should decide whether legal action is “reasonably likely” to lead to greater protection, or what evidence should support that decision.
  • It does not set rules for choosing whom to consult, how consultation must be carried out, or how views must be considered.
  • It does not specify what legal action would be taken, where it would be brought, or what grounds might support it.
  • The bill refers to an “annual report” in describing the report due within six months after the plan, but does not clearly say whether further annual reports are required.
  • The bill does not set a start date other than saying it starts when it receives Royal Assent. Passage is not certain.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to examine how illegal handguns enter and are sold in Ontario before deciding whether litigation could help address the problem.
  • A possible argument for the bill is that research and consultation could help the government judge whether manufacturers’ conduct contributes to illegal handgun supply.
  • Requiring a public plan and a report to the Assembly would make the Minister’s approach and reasoning public.
  • If the Minister finds litigation is likely to improve protection, the bill requires steps to start it rather than leaving that decision entirely open.

Case against#

  • One concern is that the bill requires research and a plan but does not set criteria, methods or deadlines for the research beyond the plan deadline.
  • The bill does not explain how litigation would reduce illegal handgun entry or what would happen if the case could not be brought or did not succeed.
  • It is unclear how much public money legal action could require, and the bill does not provide a cost estimate.
  • The Minister’s decision on whether litigation is likely to help, and whether to develop related legislation, depends on terms the bill does not define.