Summary#
Bill 24, the Pathways to Post-secondary Excellence Act (Post-secondary Educational Report), 2018, would amend Ontario’s Higher Education Quality Council of Ontario Act, 2005. Its stated goal is to help people make more informed post-secondary choices by bringing together information on admission, student experience and graduate outcomes.
- The Higher Education Quality Council of Ontario would have to collect information every school year for each program at each campus of covered post-secondary institutions, including institutions authorized to grant degrees under another Ontario law.
- The information would cover admission requirements; tuition, fees and required materials; available student aid and bursaries; class sizes; student demographics and satisfaction; graduate satisfaction, employment, further study, compensation and government student debt; loan defaults; employer satisfaction; and other information the Council considers appropriate or regulations require.
- The Council would have to publish the information on its website in a consistent, accurate and easy-to-use format. It may withhold information it determines is not ready for publication.
- The way information is collected must be approved by the Information and Privacy Commissioner. Regulations may set rules for collection and surveys, clarify information requirements and add information to collect.
- The Council would have to report to the Minister on its progress one year after the section takes effect. The Act would come into force one year after Royal Assent.
What it means for you#
- Students and families: You may be able to compare programs using the information the Council publishes. The bill does not change admission rules, tuition, student aid or program quality.
- Graduates and employers: The information could include graduate and employer satisfaction, employment and further study, compensation and government student-loan defaults. The bill does not set a process for contacting or surveying them; regulations may set survey rules.
- Post-secondary institutions: The Council’s collection would cover programs at their campuses, but the bill does not expressly require institutions to provide information or set a process for obtaining it.
- The Council: It would have a new duty to collect and publish the listed information and report to the Minister. This creates duties for the existing Council, not a new independent agency.
- Taxpayers: The bill does not set a tax, fee, fine or benefit.
Money#
No cost information is in the available material.
- The Council would have to collect and publish information, but the bill gives no estimate of the resources or costs involved.
- No payment or new funding amount is specified.
What is unclear#
- The bill does not say how the Council will obtain information from institutions or what happens if information is missing.
- The Council may decide information is not ready for publication, but the bill sets no criteria or deadline for publishing withheld information.
- The Council can collect other information it considers appropriate, and regulations may add information; the limits on those choices are not set out here.
- The bill does not specify who must answer surveys or how the results will be made comparable; regulations may set those details.
- The parent Act was not supplied, so its existing rules and how these new duties fit with them could not be verified.
Case for#
- A possible argument for the bill is that bringing program information together could make it easier for people to compare post-secondary options.
- Publishing information about costs, student experience and graduate outcomes could give prospective students a broader basis for decisions than admission information alone.
- Requiring privacy approval for the collection method and a consistent, accurate format could support careful and usable reporting.
Case against#
- The bill does not require institutions to provide information or establish a way to secure it, which could leave the Council’s ability to collect complete information unclear.
- The exception for information the Council considers not ready to publish has no stated criteria or deadline.
- Collecting and publishing extensive information could require resources, but the bill gives no cost estimate.
- The Council may decide what class-size and demographic information is appropriate and may collect other information; the bill does not explain how those choices will be limited.