Publish post-secondary program outcomes

Summary#

Bill 76, the Pathways to Post-secondary Excellence Act (Post-secondary Educational Report), 2016, would amend the Higher Education Quality Council of Ontario Act, 2005. It would require the Higher Education Quality Council of Ontario to collect and publish information about post-secondary programs; its stated goal is to help people make more informed choices. If passed, it would come into force one year after Royal Assent.

  • For each school year, the Council must collect information for programs at every campus of each post-secondary educational institution, and at institutions run by people authorized to grant degrees under the Post-secondary Education Choice and Excellence Act, 2000.
  • The information includes admission requirements; tuition, fees and required materials; available government student aid and bursaries; class-size and demographic information the Council considers appropriate; student and graduate satisfaction; graduates’ employment and further education; their average compensation, government student debt and student-loan default rates; employer satisfaction; and other information the Council or regulations require.
  • The Council must publish the information on its website in a consistent, accurate and easy-to-use format. It may withhold information it determines is not ready for publication. Collection must follow a method approved by the Information and Privacy Commissioner.
  • One year after the new section takes effect, the Council must report to the Minister on its progress. Regulations may set rules for collecting information and surveys, including who must be surveyed.

What it means for you#

  • People choosing a post-secondary program: The bill would require a central website to publish information about programs, including costs, admissions, student experience and graduate outcomes. It does not require the Council to publish information it considers not ready.
  • Students, graduates and employers: Regulations may set up surveys and specify who must be surveyed. The bill itself does not say who must respond.
  • Post-secondary institutions: The bill requires the Council to collect information about their programs. It does not expressly require institutions to provide information, or set out how the Council would obtain it.
  • The Council: It would have a recurring duty to collect and publish the listed information, and to report to the Minister on progress.

Money#

No publicly available information on the bill’s estimated public cost.

  • The bill would require ongoing information collection, publication and reporting, but gives no cost estimate or funding amount.
  • It does not set a new tax, fee, fine or student benefit.

What is unclear#

  • The supplied material does not include the existing Higher Education Quality Council of Ontario Act, 2005, so I could not verify the Council’s current duties or how these requirements would overlap with them.
  • The bill does not explain how the Council would obtain information from institutions, students, graduates or employers.
  • Regulations would determine survey details, including who must be surveyed. Those rules are not in the bill.
  • The bill does not define when information is “not ready” for publication, or give a deadline for publishing each year’s information.
  • The Council may decide what class-size and demographic information is appropriate and may collect other information. The bill does not set limits for those choices beyond the requirement for Information and Privacy Commissioner approval of the collection method.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to make information about the cost, experience and outcomes of different programs easier to compare in one place.
  • Requiring yearly information could give people a more consistent basis for comparing programs, rather than relying only on admissions information.
  • Requiring the collection method to be approved by the Information and Privacy Commissioner could provide a privacy safeguard.

Case against#

  • Much of the information depends on Council choices or future regulations, so the bill does not itself establish a complete, fixed set of comparable measures.
  • The Council may withhold information it considers not ready, without the bill setting criteria or a publication deadline.
  • The bill requires substantial ongoing data collection and publication but gives no cost estimate or funding plan.