Care Hours Standard Bill Sets Daily Hours

Summary#

Bill 43, the Time to Care Act (Long-Term Care Homes Amendment, Minimum Standard of Daily Care), 2018, would amend Ontario’s Long-Term Care Homes Act, 2007. It would set a minimum average of four combined hours of nursing and personal support services per resident each day, with a higher minimum possible by regulation. Its stated goal is to establish a minimum standard of daily care.

  • Long-term care home licensees would have to meet the average standard across the home; the bill does not guarantee four hours of care to each resident individually.
  • The calculation would exclude paid time for vacation, statutory holidays, leaves, sick time, training, and other purposes that do not involve direct patient care.
  • Care plans would have to be based on each resident’s assessment, needs, and preferences, while taking the minimum-hours duty into account.
  • Regulations could set a higher minimum and would set how the average is calculated.

What it means for you#

  • Long-term care residents: If the bill became law, the home would have to meet the average-hours minimum. This would not ensure that every resident personally receives four hours of nursing and personal support services each day.
  • Long-term care home licensees: They would have to ensure the home meets the minimum using the calculation set by regulation. The bill does not set out how to meet it.
  • Residents and their families: Care plans would have to account for residents’ assessed needs and preferences, as well as the home’s duty to meet the minimum.
  • General public: The bill text alone does not show whether Bill 43 passed or is in force. It says it would take effect six months after Royal Assent.

Money#

No publicly available information on the bill’s cost.

  • The bill requires homes to meet a minimum amount of direct-care hours, but gives no estimate of staffing or other costs and specifies no funding.
  • The bill does not set a fee, tax, fine, or benefit.

What is unclear#

  • The bill leaves the calculation of the average to regulations; those regulations are not included in the supplied material.
  • The supplied bill text does not explain which activities count as nursing or personal support services.
  • It does not set out a process for checking compliance or any new penalty for failing to meet the minimum. The parent Act was not supplied, so existing rules on these matters could not be verified.
  • It does not say how homes would pay for any additional care hours they need to provide.
  • The bill text does not show whether it became law.

Case for#

  • A minimum could set a common baseline for the combined nursing and personal support services homes must offer, rather than leaving the amount entirely to each home.
  • Excluding paid time that is not direct patient care focuses the calculation on hours involving resident care.
  • Allowing regulations to set a higher minimum could let the standard rise without changing the Act.

Case against#

  • Because the standard is an average, a home could meet it while some residents receive less than four hours and others receive more.
  • The bill leaves the calculation rules to regulations, so the standard’s practical effect would depend on details not included in the bill.
  • The bill requires homes to meet the minimum but does not specify funding or how homes should provide any additional hours.