Care Homes: Itemize Charges for Tenants

Summary#

The Protecting Seniors’ Rights in Care Homes Act, 2024 would amend Ontario’s Residential Tenancies Act, 2006 and Retirement Homes Act, 2010. Its stated goal is to protect older residents from unfair charges and loss of services. If passed, it would set rules for care-service and meal charges in care homes, and require a notice about tenant rights when a retirement home closes.

  • Care-home landlords would have to itemize charges for care services and meals, keep them consistent with the latest information package, and charge the same amount for each service or meal to every tenant in that care home.
  • Landlords could offer service packages, but would have to let tenants choose and pay for individual services. If a service or meal is reduced in quantity or quality, its charge must be reduced accordingly.
  • Most increases to care-service and meal charges could happen only once every 12 months and could not exceed the annual percentage limit in the Residential Tenancies Act. Regulations could allow exceptions, within limits set by the bill.
  • Tenants and landlords could agree in writing to add services or meals. A tenant could later give at least 10 days’ notice to reduce or stop an added service or meal.
  • Landlords would have to provide and update information packages, including charges and available services. A retirement-home licensee stopping operations would have to tell residents their tenant rights continue and that the closure notice is not a notice ending their tenancy.

What it means for you#

  • Care-home tenants: You would get information about accommodation, service options and charges before signing a tenancy agreement. You could ask to reduce or stop services or meals added later by written agreement, with at least 10 days’ notice. A coerced agreement, or one based on a landlord’s false, incomplete or misleading statement, would be void.
  • Care-home landlords: You would have to follow the charge, information-package and service-reduction rules. The bill does not set out a process for tenants to apply for a service or for landlords to review a tenant’s circumstances.
  • Retirement-home residents: If your home is closing, its licensee would have to explain that you retain your tenant rights and that the closure notice itself does not end your tenancy.
  • The public: The bill would not create a new agency or directly change taxes. It would add rules to two existing laws.

Money#

No cost estimate is included in the supplied material.

  • Landlords would have new information, pricing and notice duties, but the bill gives no estimate of the cost of meeting them or says how those costs would be paid.
  • The bill does not set a dollar amount for service charges. Most increases would be limited by the annual percentage limit in the Residential Tenancies Act; regulations could allow exceptions, but not above the bill’s stated limits.
  • No government spending, savings, fees or fines are specified in the supplied material.

What is unclear#

  • The Residential Tenancies Act, 2006 and Retirement Homes Act, 2010 were not supplied, so I could not verify the current rules, the definition and scope of “care home,” or the effect of repealing a provision in the Residential Tenancies Act.
  • The bill’s preamble says the current restriction on service-fee increases is 90 days’ notice. I could not verify that description against the current Act.
  • Regulations would set the process and evidence landlords must use to justify exceptional increases. Those regulations are not included. The bill also does not clarify how its “3 per cent a year over a three year period” limit would work in practice.
  • The bill would start one year after Royal Assent, unless brought into force earlier by proclamation. The supplied material does not say whether it has received Royal Assent.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to make care charges easier to check by requiring itemized charges and updated information packages.
  • Limiting increases could help tenants avoid sudden or repeated increases in charges for services and meals.
  • Requiring a lower charge when a service or meal is reduced could better match what tenants pay to what they receive.
  • Letting tenants choose individual services and stop added services could give them more control over optional costs.

Case against#

  • Limits on increases could make it harder for landlords to raise charges when their costs rise; the bill allows exceptions, but regulations would determine how those work.
  • The same-charge rule may limit a landlord’s ability to set different prices for the same service or meal, even if tenants’ circumstances differ.
  • The bill leaves important details to future regulations, including how landlords must justify exceptional increases.
  • The bill adds duties for landlords but does not estimate their compliance costs or explain whether those costs might affect other charges.