Tenant Privacy Rules Tightened for Showings

Summary#

Bill 45, the Residential Tenancies Amendment Act (Tenant Privacy), 2018, would amend Ontario’s Residential Tenancies Act, 2006. Its stated goal is to protect tenants’ privacy during showings and when photographs or other visual records are taken. The supplied material does not give the parent Act, so the current rules being changed could not be checked.

  • A landlord could enter to show a unit to prospective tenants only after the tenancy has been agreed to end or either side has given notice to end it, and only between 8 a.m. and 8 p.m. The bill’s explanatory note says written notice is required; the supplied bill text does not set out the notice period.
  • A landlord, or a broker or salesperson authorized in writing by the landlord, could hold an open house for a unit on the market for sale after giving the tenant written notice at least seven days in advance. The number and frequency of open houses must be reasonable.
  • A landlord, broker or salesperson could take a photograph or other visual record inside a unit only after giving written notice with specified details and receiving the tenant’s written consent at least 48 hours before the recording. The recording must follow the notice’s limits on area, purpose, use, time and retention.
  • A recording made in violation of those rules could not be used as evidence against the tenant. The bill would also let the Landlord and Tenant Board determine whether a landlord, superintendent or agent took a recording in violation of the rules, and would add the violation to the Act’s offence provisions.
  • If enacted, the bill would start one month after Royal Assent.

What it means for you#

  • Tenants: You would have specific protections around open houses and recordings. For a recording, your written consent would be required; the bill does not say that a landlord may record if you do not respond.
  • Tenants whose rental is ending: The bill would allow entry to show the unit to prospective tenants only if the tenancy is ending by agreement or notice, and only from 8 a.m. to 8 p.m. The exact notice rules depend on provisions of the existing Act that were not supplied.
  • Landlords, brokers and salespeople: You would have to follow the seven-day written-notice rule for open houses and the detailed notice, consent and recording limits. A broker or salesperson could hold an open house only with the landlord’s written authorization.
  • Tenants and landlords: The bill does not ban showings or open houses, but it limits when they can happen and how open houses must be arranged. It does not give the Board a new power to decide every dispute about entry; the new order is specifically about a recording taken in violation of the rules.

Money#

No publicly available information on estimated public or private costs.

  • The bill does not state a budget, staffing amount, fee or fine amount.
  • Landlords, brokers and salespeople may have costs from complying with the notice and recording rules; no estimate is provided.
  • The bill adds a recording violation to the offence provisions, but the supplied material does not state the applicable penalty.

What is unclear#

  • The current entry rules, including the usual written-notice requirements, could not be verified because the parent Act was not supplied.
  • The bill does not define what number or frequency of open houses is “reasonable.”
  • It does not set a minimum period between the written notice about a recording and the tenant’s consent, beyond requiring consent at least 48 hours before the recording.
  • The bill does not explain how the new Board order fits with other remedies under the existing Act, or what penalty applies to the new offence.
  • No start date is given apart from one month after Royal Assent; the supplied material does not say whether the bill became law.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to give tenants more control over images of their homes, which may show personal belongings or private spaces.
  • Requiring consent and limiting the recording to the stated area, purpose, use and retention period could make the tenant’s choice more specific.
  • Advance notice and limits on open-house frequency could help tenants prepare for visits while still allowing a sale.

Case against#

  • One concern is that the bill adds detailed requirements for photographs but does not explain how disputes about consent or compliance would be resolved before a recording is taken.
  • The meaning of a “reasonable” number and frequency of open houses is unclear, which could lead to disagreements.
  • The bill may make arranging showings or marketing a unit more difficult, especially because open houses require seven days’ notice and recordings require written consent. The materials do not estimate these effects or costs.