Summary#
Bill 144, Real Rent Control Act, 2017, would amend Ontario’s Residential Tenancies Act, 2006, including changes made by the Rental Fairness Act, 2017. Its apparent goal is to strengthen rent limits and enforcement of landlords’ repair duties. The supplied material does not include the current Act, so the full change from current law cannot be independently verified.
- The Landlord and Tenant Board would have to create and maintain a rent registry. Landlords would have to file rent and contact information for each rental unit and give a copy to the tenant.
- For most new tenancies, rent could not exceed the previous lawful rent, with an adjustment in some cases where the unit was not rented in the last 12 months. If the unit has never been rented, the bill does not cap the first rent.
- Tenants could apply to the Board without notice if a landlord misses a deadline for repairs or other work in a mediated settlement or prior Board order. The Board could order a daily fine of up to $1,000, a rent reduction, or both.
- Landlords could seek an above-guideline rent increase only for eligible capital expenditures: major repairs or replacements that meet specified criteria, benefit tenants, and are assessed under regulations.
- Landlords could not raise rent for a unit until they file its registry statement. The Board could also refuse or pause an applicant’s Board case if the applicant owes Board money or has not filed a required statement.
What it means for you#
- Tenants: For a previously rented unit, the bill would generally tie a new tenant’s rent to the last lawful rent, subject to the bill’s rules and an exception for units never previously rented. A tenant charged more than the lawful maximum could seek a Board order requiring the landlord to repay the excess.
- Tenants: A tenant could request registry information about their unit, and a prospective tenant could do so after applying to rent it. A tenant has 60 days after receiving the landlord’s statement to ask the Board to check its accuracy.
- Tenants: If a landlord does not complete work required by a qualifying settlement or order by the deadline, the tenant could apply without first giving notice. The Board would have to find non-compliance before making the listed orders.
- Landlords: They would have to file a statement for every covered unit, provide a copy to the tenant, and include required rent, service and utility details. The bill also makes failing to file or giving false information an offence; the supplied text does not give the penalty.
- Landlords: They could apply for an above-guideline increase only on the bill’s eligible-capital-expenditure grounds. Their application would have to disclose specified unfinished repair or maintenance work.
- Board and tenants: The registry would be run by the existing Landlord and Tenant Board, not a new independent agency. The Board could share registry information with tax authorities; access to unit-specific information is otherwise limited to listed people.
- General public: The bill would not make the full registry publicly searchable.
Money#
No cost information is in the available material.
- The Board would have to establish and maintain the registry, but no staffing or operating-cost estimate is given.
- Landlords would have filing duties, but no compliance-cost estimate is given.
- The Board could order landlords to pay an administrative fine of up to $1,000 per day for failing to complete covered work. The bill does not estimate how often fines would be imposed or how much revenue they would raise.
What is unclear#
- The bill does not define key terms such as “benefits the tenants” or explain how regulations would decide which capital expenditures qualify.
- The supplied text does not include the current Residential Tenancies Act or the full Rental Fairness Act amendments. The exact comparison with current law, including some detailed above-guideline increase rules, cannot be verified.
- The bill leaves registry forms, other required information, disclosure rules and some procedures to Board rules or regulations.
- It does not set out the full hearing process, timelines or appeal rights for the new repair-enforcement application.
- The supplied material does not establish whether the bill passed. It says most of these changes would start six months after Royal Assent.
Case for#
- The rent rules could make it harder to raise rent sharply between tenants in units that were recently rented.
- A registry could give tenants and prospective tenants a way to check the rent and other recorded details for a particular unit.
- The new application process could give tenants a direct way to seek remedies when a landlord misses a repair deadline in a settlement or order.
- Restricting above-guideline increases to specified major capital work could link those increases more closely to improvements that benefit tenants.
Case against#
- Tying rent for a new tenant to a previous lawful rent could limit a landlord’s ability to set a different rent after a tenancy ends. The bill does not apply that limit to a unit never previously rented.
- The Board would take on registry duties and new case-handling tasks without a stated budget or staffing plan.
- Eligibility for above-guideline increases would depend partly on regulations and terms the bill does not define, leaving important details unsettled.
- The registry would contain personal and rent information, and the bill permits sharing some information with tax authorities. It does not explain how long records would be kept or how privacy risks would be managed.