Summary#
Bill 129, the Safe and Healthy Communities Act (Addressing Gun Violence), 2019, would amend Ontario’s Health Insurance Act and Health Protection and Promotion Act. Its stated goal is to address gun violence and its effects by adding insured health services and duties for boards of health.
- Prescribed hospital-based violence intervention programs and prescribed trauma-informed counselling would become insured services. The counselling could be accessed without a time limit, but would still be subject to prescribed conditions and limitations.
- The counselling provision names survivors of gun violence, impacted family members and observers. It must be provided by prescribed practitioners.
- Boards of health would have to provide programs and services to reduce gun violence and to increase community capacity to support the well-being of survivors and people with trauma associated with gun violence.
- The changes would start six months after Royal Assent.
What it means for you#
- Survivors, impacted family members and observers: The bill would make prescribed trauma-informed counselling an insured service, with no time limit on accessing it. It does not specify which practitioners or counselling conditions would qualify.
- People affected by gun violence: Prescribed hospital-based violence intervention programs would also be insured services. The bill does not require every hospital to offer them.
- Boards of health: They would have a duty to provide programs and services in the two areas listed above.
- General public: The bill does not change gun ownership rules or create a new direct service for everyone.
Money#
No publicly available information on cost is included in the supplied material.
- The new insured services and required board programs may involve public spending, but the bill gives no cost estimate, funding amount or staffing details.
What is unclear#
- The bill leaves key details to be prescribed, including which intervention programs, counselling, practitioners, conditions and limitations qualify.
- It does not set out how broad the boards’ programs must be, how they would be delivered or how their work would be funded.
- The supplied material does not include the current versions of the two Acts, so existing duties and how the amendments would fit with them could not be verified.
- The bill does not explain how hospitals would make the insured programs available in practice.
Case for#
- A possible argument for the bill is that it would recognize counselling and hospital-based intervention as insured services for people affected by gun violence.
- The absence of a time limit on accessing the counselling could allow people to seek it later, rather than only within a set period.
- Requiring boards of health to address both reducing gun violence and building community capacity could support a broader public-health response.
Case against#
- The bill leaves much of the actual coverage to later rules, so the services and people eligible for them are not clear from the bill itself.
- It requires boards of health to provide programs but does not specify their scale, funding or staffing.
- Making hospital-based programs insured does not itself require hospitals to offer them, so the bill does not guarantee their availability.