Summary#
Bill 9, the Safe and Healthy Communities Act (Addressing Gun Violence), 2022, would amend Ontario’s Health Insurance Act and Health Protection and Promotion Act. Its stated goal is to address gun violence and its effects.
- It would add certain prescribed hospital- and community-based violence intervention programs, and trauma-informed counselling, to the services that count as insured services.
- Counselling would be for gun-violence survivors, impacted family members and observers, provided by prescribed practitioners under conditions and limits set later. The bill says there would be no time limit on accessing the counselling.
- Boards of health would have to provide programs and services to reduce gun violence and to build community capacity to support the well-being of survivors and people with trauma associated with gun violence.
- The bill would take effect six months after Royal Assent. It would not directly change firearm rules such as licensing or possession.
What it means for you#
- Survivors, family members and observers: The bill would make prescribed trauma-informed counselling an insured service, with no time limit for accessing it. Which counselling and practitioners qualify, and other conditions or limits, would be set later.
- People affected by gun violence and local communities: Boards of health would have to provide programs and services for gun-violence reduction and to increase community capacity to support people affected.
- Boards of health: They would have a new stated duty to provide those programs and services. The bill does not set out what the programs must include.
- Researchers, service providers and the general public: The bill does not create a separate agency or set out an application, referral, approval or appeal process.
Money#
No publicly available information on the bill’s cost.
- The bill does not state an appropriation, fee, or cost estimate.
- It would make specified services insured, but the services and practitioners covered would depend on later rules. The bill gives no estimate of related spending.
- Boards of health would have to provide programs and services, but the bill gives no staffing or cost figures.
What is unclear#
- Which intervention programs, counselling services and practitioners would be prescribed, and what conditions or limits would apply.
- How people would find or access the services, and how boards of health would meet their new duties.
- What “increasing the capacity of the community” means in practice, and how survivors and others affected would be involved.
- The supplied material does not include the parent Acts. I could not verify what the current laws already require or how these additions would interact with existing duties and services.
- No publicly available information in the supplied material says whether regulations, funding or implementation plans are ready.
Case for#
- The bill appears intended to address both gun-violence reduction and the effects on survivors and other people affected.
- Making prescribed counselling an insured service could reduce a financial barrier for people who qualify.
- Requiring boards of health to provide relevant programs and services could make community support part of their public-health work.
- The no-time-limit rule for accessing counselling could help people who are not ready to seek support right away.
Case against#
- The bill leaves key decisions to later rules, so the range of services, eligible practitioners and limits is not yet clear.
- It requires boards of health to provide programs and services without specifying what they must provide or how much funding or staff they will need.
- The bill does not explain how people will access services or how their quality and availability will be checked.
- “No time limit” applies to accessing counselling; the bill does not say whether the counselling itself would have limits on duration or number of sessions.