Summary#
Bill 158, the Defibrillator Training and Access Act, 2019, would create a new law; it does not amend an existing Act. Its stated goal is to improve public access to defibrillators and training. The law would start on a day set by proclamation.
- The Minister must designate a registrar. Owners of premises named in future regulations would have to install defibrillators, make them available for use, take reasonable steps to maintain and test them, and ensure prescribed people undertake prescribed training.
- Owners would have to register each defibrillator within 30 days after installation, provide its location and other required information, and notify the registrar if it is moved or removed. The registrar must notify emergency service providers and other prescribed people about registrations and changes.
- The Minister may appoint inspectors. They could enter designated premises that are not dwellings, without a warrant or notice, at a reasonable time to inspect compliance and examine documents or other relevant things.
- Breaking the requirements, interfering with an inspector, or providing false information or hiding or destroying relevant things would be offences. Maximum fines range from $3,000 to $25,000, depending on the offender and whether it is a first or later offence.
What it means for you#
- Owners of designated premises: You would have to meet the installation, access, maintenance, testing, registration and training requirements. Regulations would decide which premises are covered and many details of those requirements. An owner could face a fine for an offence.
- People who use those premises: The bill aims to make defibrillators available, but it does not set out who may use them, guarantee access at all times, or give people a right to training.
- Emergency service providers: The registrar must notify them about registered devices and changes to their location, as set out in regulations.
- Taxpayers and public bodies: The law would allow the Minister to appoint inspectors and require a registrar to be designated. The bill does not say how many staff would be needed or how the work would be funded.
Money#
No cost estimate is provided in the available material.
- Owners would have to pay for required devices, installation, maintenance, testing and training, but the bill gives no cost figures.
- The bill allows the Minister to appoint inspectors and requires a registrar to be designated. It does not estimate the cost of those roles.
- The bill sets maximum fines, but does not estimate how many offences or fines there might be.
What is unclear#
- Regulations would determine which public-access premises are designated. The bill does not name the premises that must have defibrillators.
- The bill leaves many practical rules to regulations, including device placement, availability for use, registration details, maintenance and testing guidelines, and who must be trained.
- The bill does not set out how the registrar will be chosen, how quickly notifications must be sent, or what registration information beyond location will be required.
- It does not state when the Act would start; that date would be set by proclamation.
- The bill does not explain how its requirements would interact with any existing defibrillator programs.
Case for#
- The bill appears intended to make defibrillators available in public places where people may experience cardiac arrest.
- Requiring owners to maintain and test devices could help ensure they are ready for use.
- Registration and location notices could help emergency service providers know where devices are located.
- Requiring training for people named in regulations could support the bill’s goal of improving access to trained users.
Case against#
- A large part of the scheme depends on future regulations. Until those rules are made, it is unclear which premises and people would be covered, and what owners would have to do.
- Owners would face equipment, upkeep and training duties, but the bill provides no cost estimates or funding plan.
- Inspectors could enter covered premises that are not dwellings without a warrant or notice. The bill gives them broad powers to examine documents and question people, while setting no inspection schedule or appeal process.
- The bill does not itself ensure that a device will be accessible whenever needed or that a trained person will be present.