Firefighter training safety standards bill

Summary#

Bill 10, the Brunt and Kendall Act (Ensuring Safe Firefighter and Trainee Rescue Training), 2018, would amend Ontario’s Fire Protection and Prevention Act, 1997 and Private Career Colleges Act, 2005. It would add rules for rescue and emergency-services training, with the stated goal of making that training safer.

  • The Fire Marshal would have to develop and maintain minimum safety standards, publish them, and provide for certification of rescue training courses before they are offered. The standards must meet or exceed applicable National Fire Protection Association standards and take relevant local factors into account.
  • The Minister would have to establish an expert committee to review the standards. The Fire Marshal would have to consider its recommendations, make any necessary changes, and report on recommendations not implemented.
  • Private providers would need a Fire Marshal licence. They would have to meet requirements set by regulation, carry required liability insurance, and follow other licence conditions. The Fire Marshal would publish registries of certified courses and licensed providers.
  • Fire chiefs would have to ensure courses provided within their fire departments follow the new requirements. Private providers would have to use written contracts with trainees and firefighters; only the Fire Marshal could confirm completion of those providers’ courses.
  • Inspectors could enter and inspect premises without a warrant to check compliance, and could order a course to stop in specified circumstances. The bill also creates offences for breaking its prohibitions.

What it means for you#

  • Firefighters and trainees: You could take only a course certified by the Fire Marshal. For a course from a private provider, you would need a written contract; if a fee is charged, the provider would have to give you a written record of fees paid and refunds. The Fire Marshal—not the provider—would issue written confirmation of successful completion.
  • Fire departments and fire chiefs: The chief would have to ensure department courses comply. People providing a course, and others specified by the Fire Marshal, would have to sign a form before an exercise. It would set out roles and safety responsibilities, identify who is in charge, and, for an exercise at a workplace, identify who is in charge of that workplace.
  • Private providers: You would need a licence to offer or provide courses, and would have to cooperate with inspections and follow inspector orders. The bill defines private providers to exclude certain public colleges, registered private career colleges, and department members acting in their duties; those exclusions do not exempt their courses from certification.
  • Private career colleges: The Superintendent could not approve a rescue training course unless it is certified, and must revoke approval if certification ends.
  • People taking courses within fire departments: The bill’s injury-and-death reporting rule does not apply to courses provided to firefighters within fire departments. Other course requirements still apply.

Money#

The bill requires the Fire Marshal’s office to take on new duties and allows the Fire Marshal to employ staff, but the available material gives no cost estimate.

  • Private providers would have to pay prescribed licensing fees and carry liability insurance in the amount and form set by regulation.
  • The bill does not set course prices or say who would pay any prescribed fees.
  • It creates offences, but the supplied material does not give the penalty amounts.

What is unclear#

  • The bill leaves key details to regulations, including provider qualifications, application procedures, fees, insurance requirements, and some licence conditions.
  • It does not set out the certification application process, decision timelines, or an appeal process for course certification. It allows regulations to set some licensing appeals and hearing rights.
  • “Significant change” to a course—which would end its certification unless the Fire Marshal approves the change in advance—is not defined in the bill.
  • The bill does not give a start date. It would start on a date set by proclamation or, if earlier, one year after Royal Assent.

Case for#

  • A required safety baseline could make course requirements clearer for providers, fire departments, firefighters, and trainees.
  • Requiring certification before a course is offered, and allowing inspectors to order unsafe or non-compliant courses to stop, could help prevent avoidable training risks.
  • Expert reviews and required updates could help keep standards current as national standards change.
  • Publishing standards, course and provider registries, and injury statistics could make information easier to find.

Case against#

  • The Fire Marshal would control standards, course certification, private-provider licences, and some licence conditions. The bill does not set out a full certification process or timelines.
  • New standards, certification, staffing, insurance, and licensing requirements could cost public agencies and private providers money; the bill gives no estimate.
  • The bill requires injury reporting for courses outside fire departments but exempts courses provided to firefighters within departments. That could leave a gap in the published injury statistics.
  • Some requirements depend on future regulations, so providers and trainees cannot tell from the bill alone exactly what qualifications, fees, insurance, or procedures will apply.