Summary#
The Legislative Assembly Amendment Act, 2020 amends Ontario’s Legislative Assembly Act and makes related changes to two other Acts. It was enacted as Chapter 15 of Ontario’s 2020 statutes. Its stated purpose is not set out in the supplied material; the changes mainly set rules for the Assembly’s leadership, staff, precinct and security.
- The Assembly must appoint a Deputy Speaker by order; it no longer elects one. The Speaker remains elected.
- The Speaker is named guardian of the Assembly’s, committees’ and members’ rights, immunities, privileges and powers. They also receive the same rights, immunities, privileges and powers as the UK House of Commons, its committees and members held in 1867.
- The Speaker controls the defined legislative precinct. Personal service of civil legal documents is prohibited there.
- The Legislative Protective Service may secure nearby premises if the Speaker and the owner or occupier agree. The Speaker may issue service guidelines and authorize selected peace officers to possess and use weapons, including firearms. Those officers have police powers for their duties, subject to exceptions set by regulation.
- The Speaker appoints most Office of the Assembly employees and may dismiss, suspend or reprimand them. The Act repeals provisions for employee discipline and related hearings.
- Employees must swear or affirm an office oath recognizing Indigenous and treaty rights. Some employees may be exempt from the separate oath of allegiance to the Crown. Payments from the Legislative Assembly Fund require authorization by both the Speaker or Deputy Speaker and the Clerk or another person authorized by the Speaker.
What it means for you#
- Assembly members and committees: The Act sets out their rights and privileges and makes the Speaker their guardian. The Board of Internal Economy’s proceedings are declared to be proceedings in Parliament.
- Assembly employees: Before receiving salary, employees must take the office oath or affirmation. An employee who is not a Canadian citizen may be exempt from the Crown allegiance oath if they assert it could cost them their other citizenship. An Indigenous employee may be exempt if they assert the oath conflicts with their views on the relationship between the Crown and Indigenous peoples.
- Assembly employees and taxpayers: The Speaker may appoint, dismiss, suspend or reprimand most Assembly Office employees. The Act removes the stated statutory discipline and hearing provisions; the supplied material does not describe a replacement hearing process.
- People in the legislative precinct: Personal service of civil legal documents is prohibited there. The precinct includes the Legislative Building and specified nearby spaces, as well as areas where parliamentary proceedings take place and any other areas designated by the Lieutenant Governor in Council. It excludes members’ constituency offices.
- People near the precinct: The Protective Service may provide physical protection and security at nearby premises only under an agreement between the Speaker and the owner or occupier. The Act does not require those owners or occupiers to make an agreement.
- Members of the public: The Act does not directly change taxes, public benefits or general access to services.
Money#
No cost information is in the available material.
- The Act requires payments from the Legislative Assembly Fund to have two authorizations, but provides no spending estimate.
- It gives the Speaker power to appoint staff and to authorize selected Protective Service officers to use weapons. It provides no staffing or equipment cost estimate.
- The Act says each Assembly member is entitled to staff, equipment, supplies and services as the Board of Internal Economy prescribes. It gives no cost figure for those items.
What is unclear#
- The supplied material does not include the previous or current consolidated Legislative Assembly Act, so the full effect of the amendments against current law cannot be verified.
- The Act does not give criteria for designating additional areas as part of the precinct.
- It does not set out reporting or oversight requirements for Protective Service work, or explain how complaints about that work are handled.
- The Lieutenant Governor in Council may prescribe Acts that limit peace officers’ police powers; the supplied text does not identify which Acts will be prescribed.
- The Act does not say how employee discipline will be handled after the provisions for discipline and hearings are repealed.
- It gives no criteria or process for deciding what staff, equipment, supplies and services members receive.
Case for#
- The Act gives the Assembly and its members a clear statement of their rights and powers, and assigns the Speaker responsibility for protecting them.
- Putting precinct control with the Speaker may support consistent security decisions for Assembly premises.
- Allowing security agreements for nearby premises may let the Protective Service respond to security needs beyond the precinct, with the owner’s or occupier’s agreement.
- The changes to employee oaths recognize Indigenous and treaty rights and provide specific exemptions from the Crown allegiance oath.
Case against#
- The Speaker receives substantial control over the precinct, staff and security guidelines, while the supplied text gives few details about oversight or review.
- Removing the statutory discipline and hearing provisions may leave employees with fewer protections in the Act; the bill does not explain what process replaces them.
- The Speaker may authorize selected peace officers to use weapons, including firearms, and grant them police powers. The bill does not set out detailed limits or reporting requirements.
- The Act’s broad precinct definition can include additional designated areas, but the text provides no criteria for those designations.