Summary#
Bill 75, the Queen’s Park Restoration Act, 2023, was enacted as an Act that creates a ministry and amends the Legislative Assembly Act and the Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy Act. Its stated goal is to restore and preserve the Legislative Building while keeping the Assembly functioning. The schedules require proclamation to come into force; the supplied material gives no proclamation dates.
- The new Queen’s Park Restoration Secretariat is a ministry, not an independent agency. Its Minister must lead the restoration project, find and prepare a suitable temporary location for the Assembly, and seek stable, secure project funding.
- The Minister must consult a standing committee, report to it on general plans, seek the Board of Internal Economy’s advice, and give the Board progress reports at least every three months. The Minister must take reasonable steps to carry out Board requests or explain in detail why a request should not be implemented.
- The Lieutenant Governor in Council may make regulations changing the legislative precinct’s boundaries and creating a restoration zone. The Minister must recommend these regulations, and the Board must give written approval after consultation; a restoration zone would be under the Minister’s control.
- The Act changes the Board’s membership rules to include alternate commissioners and gives the Board a role advising the Secretariat. It also permits the Board or Speaker, in specified circumstances, to delegate certain powers, duties or control to a minister for project preparation.
- The Act changes the Legislative Protective Service’s stated duties and permits it to protect premises outside the precinct under an agreement or the Speaker’s written directive. The Speaker decides whether to make related guidelines, directives or authorizations public.
- Records prepared by the Assembly with respect to the project are excluded from the Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy Act until 20 years after the Secretariat Act is repealed.
What it means for you#
- Taxpayers: The Secretariat may hire employees and enter into contracts for the project. The Minister must seek stable, secure funding, but the Act does not set a budget.
- People seeking government records: The named project records would not be subject to the provincial freedom-of-information law until 20 years after the Secretariat Act is repealed.
- Assembly members and staff: The Board and a standing committee have formal consultation and advice roles. The Deputy Minister or a representative must routinely consult the Clerk about the Office of the Assembly’s and Board’s needs and interests.
- People at or near Queen’s Park: Security may be provided outside the precinct by agreement with a property owner or occupier, or under a written directive from the Speaker. The Act does not itself say that all nearby areas will be covered.
- General public: The Act does not set public access rules for the temporary Assembly location or create a public application or complaint process.
Money#
The Act permits staffing and contracts, but no cost estimate is in the available material.
- The Minister must seek stable, secure funding; the Act does not appropriate a specific amount.
- Employees may be appointed as needed. The Lieutenant Governor in Council may set pay and expenses for advisory committee members.
- No publicly available information on the project’s total cost, funding source, or expected savings is supplied.
What is unclear#
- The schedules come into force by proclamation, but the material gives no dates. No publicly available information.
- The Legislative Assembly Act is not supplied, so the existing powers in sections 102.2 and 103.1—and how the new delegation authority changes them—could not be verified against current law.
- The Act does not set a project budget, completion date, procurement rules, or detailed public reporting requirements.
- The Minister decides when the project is complete. The Act does not set criteria for that decision.
- The records exclusion lasts until 20 years after the Secretariat Act is repealed, but the Act does not set when repeal will happen.
Case for#
- The project includes the building, its systems and grounds, the Lieutenant Governor’s office, and arrangements needed for the Assembly to keep functioning. Putting responsibility in one ministry may support coordination across that work.
- Regular progress reports and input from the Board, committee and Clerk create formal channels for Assembly oversight and advice.
- The power to adjust the precinct or establish a restoration zone may let the government adapt the area under project arrangements, with Board written approval required for regulations.
Case against#
- The Minister controls the project and any restoration zone, while key project details, including cost and completion criteria, are not set in the Act.
- The records exclusion may limit public access to project-related records for a long period; the Act gives no alternative public disclosure process.
- The Minister must consider Board advice and take reasonable steps to implement its requests, but can decline a request by explaining why. The Act does not make the Board’s requests binding.
- The Speaker has sole discretion over whether to publish certain security guidelines, directives or authorizations. The Act does not require those materials to be made public.