Seniors' Advocate Bill Creates Office

Summary#

Bill 196, the Seniors’ Advocate Act, 2020, would create a new Act and an independent Seniors’ Advocate who is an officer of the Ontario Legislative Assembly. Its stated goal is to address systemic challenges affecting seniors and improve their welfare; the bill does not guarantee particular results.

  • The Advocate must monitor seniors’ services, analyze Ontario government policies and issues affecting seniors’ welfare, and advocate for seniors and family caregivers.
  • The Advocate must advise the Minister, public officials and service funders or providers on systemic challenges, ways to address them, and other matters that come to the Advocate’s attention.
  • The Advocate may recommend changes, collaborate with service funders or providers, and report publicly. An annual report is required.
  • The Advocate may request non-personal information from service funders or providers only after they have failed to provide it following an earlier request, or provided information the Advocate believes is incomplete, false or misleading. If they have custody or control of the information, they must provide it within the reasonable time limit set by the Advocate.
  • The Assembly would appoint the Advocate, normally after unanimous agreement by a panel with one member from each recognized party. The Advocate would serve for five years and could be reappointed once.

What it means for you#

  • Seniors aged 65 and older, and family caregivers: The Advocate must represent their interests and examine issues affecting seniors’ welfare. If the Advocate learns of an individual matter better handled as a complaint, the Advocate may refer it—with the person’s consent—to the responsible person or body. The bill does not create a process for the Advocate to decide individual complaints.
  • Organizations that fund or deliver seniors’ services, including government: They may be asked to provide information under the conditions set out above. The bill also allows the Advocate to collaborate with them and recommend changes to them.
  • People who assist the Advocate: No person may take a measure that adversely affects someone because they provided information to or otherwise assisted the Advocate.
  • Public: The Advocate may report publicly on matters that come to their attention while doing the job. The annual report must be posted online and provided to the Assembly.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The bill does not state a budget, salary, staffing level or cost estimate for the office.
  • It creates an office and duties but does not set out an appropriation or funding source.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not set out how people can bring issues to the Advocate, how the Advocate chooses what to examine, or timelines for that work.
  • It does not specify what happens if an organization does not provide requested information.
  • The bill applies several provisions of Ontario’s Ombudsman Act to the Advocate, with changes. The supplied material does not include that Act, so the effects of those imported provisions cannot be verified here.
  • The bill does not require service funders or providers, or the government, to respond to the Advocate’s recommendations.
  • The bill would start on Royal Assent, but the supplied material does not establish whether it passed or received Royal Assent.

Case for#

  • A separate, independent officer could examine problems that affect seniors across services, rather than only handling one person’s case at a time.
  • The Advocate’s required advice and possible public reports could bring systemic problems and possible remedies to the attention of government and service providers.
  • Including family caregivers in the Advocate’s mandate and in any advisory council could bring their concerns into the work.
  • The information-request power could help the Advocate do the job when an organization has already failed to provide information or has provided information the Advocate believes is unreliable.

Case against#

  • The bill gives the Advocate a broad role but does not set out how issues are selected, how investigations proceed, or how recommendations must be acted on.
  • The information-request power is limited to specific circumstances, and the bill itself does not explain the consequences if an organization does not comply.
  • The office could require public resources, but the bill provides no budget or staffing estimate.
  • The bill does not explain how the Advocate’s work would fit with existing complaint or oversight processes.

Votes

The recorded vote on this bill, member by member.

  1. Division No. 2020101901

    Passed65 members voted

    Second Reading of Bill 196

    FOR · 65

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    65For

    • PC35
    • NDP24
    • Liberal5
    • Green1

    0Against